Starting up a Achievement/Trophy cheat committee

[NightstrikerX]

Rainbird said:
I would like to help, although currently I only have two games sitting at 75%+, and I wont start getting trophies for the sake of reaching 75%.

But before I start doing anything, I want to know how DLC trophies/achievements come into the picture. I have the platinum trophy in Mirror's Edge for example, but I am only sitting at 85% trophy completion.

Should we add those as seperate guides or do we want them included in one guide?

I would like to see the main game trophies in a guide for themselves, and then a guide for DLC a, a guide for DLC b, etc.

I'd personally like to see them all in the same file, anchored so that it is divided against the original DLC. So that a guide may appear more like this.

 

1.1 Original Game Achievements

• (Achievement)
• (Achievement)
• (Achievement)

1.2 DLC 1 Game Achievements

• (Achievement)
• (Achievement)
• (Achievement)

1.3 DLC 2 Game Achievements

• (Achievement)
• (Achievement)
• (Achievement)

1.1 - Original Game Achievements

(Achievement 2 or Trophy name) – (Achievement or Trophy Description) – (Gamerscore # or Trophy Level)

• (Guide/How-to list of steps)

(Achievement 2 or Trophy name) – (Achievement or Trophy Description) – (Gamerscore # or Trophy Level)

• (Guide/How-to list of steps)

(Achievement 2 or Trophy name) – (Achievement or Trophy Description) – (Gamerscore # or Trophy Level)

• (Guide/How-to list of steps)

1.2 - DLC 1 Achievements

(Achievement 2 or Trophy name) – (Achievement or Trophy Description) – (Gamerscore # or Trophy Level)

• (Guide/How-to list of steps)

(Achievement 2 or Trophy name) – (Achievement or Trophy Description) – (Gamerscore # or Trophy Level)

• (Guide/How-to list of steps)

(Achievement 2 or Trophy name) – (Achievement or Trophy Description) – (Gamerscore # or Trophy Level)

• (Guide/How-to list of steps)

1.3 - DLC 2 Achievements

(Achievement 2 or Trophy name) – (Achievement or Trophy Description) – (Gamerscore # or Trophy Level)

• (Guide/How-to list of steps)

(Achievement 2 or Trophy name) – (Achievement or Trophy Description) – (Gamerscore # or Trophy Level)

• (Guide/How-to list of steps)

(Achievement 2 or Trophy name) – (Achievement or Trophy Description) – (Gamerscore # or Trophy Level)

• (Guide/How-to list of steps)

As you can see, very neat and tidy. Although it is your own judgement whether not to break up DLC achievements in seperate files or keep them in a single file. Depending on games, Some games like Nuts & Bolts has up to 10 achievements on it's DLC alone. While mass effect only has 1. Other games like Fallout 3 has now 4 DLC with a 5th on the way? Each with about 3-4 achievements? Make a call there. I know you won't make a wrong choice.