The orange box highest rated game of all time?

[GooseGaws]

I agree that games are compared against other platforms in order to determine the best version, but (good) reviews are based against other games available on the same platform. I don't really understand your comment about the PS3 version of Madden being the best Madden on the PS3 (isn't it the best Madden on PS3 by default?), though. Anyway, what I mean is, as these games have not been properly available before on the 360, the package as a whole is more worthwhile for 360 gamers compared to all other 360 games than the PC version is against all other PC games. It's kind of an abstract statement, I know...