Joystiq Gives the E3 Crown to Sony

[Kantor]

ZenfoldorVGI said:

JEDE3 said:

ZenfoldorVGI said:

A. They gave them credit for the PSP stuff, this is "Sony won" not the "PS3 won"

B. They directly gave them credit for games that weren't even shown. They even admit that.

Fallacious.

Who ever ever ever ever said PS3 won? Everyone who thinks it wasn't MS doesn't refer to Sony's confrence as Ps3.

judging by your post history though....

A. Bringing my post history into this is getting a little personal isn't it? Why don't we stick to the argument at hand.

B. NOBODY ever said the PS3 won. It's either "The 360 won" or "Sony won" Without the PSP stuff, the Sony conference was relatively shallow.

Anymore questions?

I was fair minded in my posts on this thread. I don't understand why you took offense.

My two points are absolutely correct. Read the article.

A. Your post history is pretty telling, but fair enough.

B. (A.) That would be because Microsoft only has one console, while Sony has two (three, actually). If there was a Microsoft portable, it would be "Sony won" or "Microsoft won". And I've never heard anyone saying "the 360 won" either- it's always done by company. I don't remember a PS3 or 360 conference, they were Sony and Microsoft. It's perfectly fair to count the PSP as part of Sony's showing, considering how much Sony have linked it with the PS3.

B. (B.) They were shown, just not in the conference.