When does "Hyping" become "Over-hyping?"

[Euphoria14]

Mr Khan said:

Over-hyping, as said before, is just when hype gets completely out of control, to the point where the game in question absolutely cannot deliver. This occurred for GTAIV and Halo 3, as well as possibly for Red Steel, and definitely for LBP and Killzone 2

 

LBP scored a 95... how did it not deliver?

KZ2 scored a 92... same question.

Halo 3 scored a 94 and people still play it online to this day.

Only games I see on that list that released and later on recieved a lot of hate from it's userbase were Redsteel and more notably GTA IV.

Unless of course you are talking about sales which in that case you remove GTA IV and Halo 3 from your list. Although hype most of the time is in regards to quality and not necessarily sales.