Kantor on 28 April 2009
Shadow of the Colossus' appearance on that list proves that it's completely baseless and fake. It isn't SoTC. It isn't SoTC2. Anybody who has fully played and completed the game would know that a direct sequel is impossible.
It would have the same relationship as Ico and SoTC- same universe, completely different gameplay. I'm guessing between SoTC and Ico, or maybe after Ico. Perhaps even before SoTC. So it could be anything really 
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
