| Khuutra said: Well, that's what I mean to ask: working from the ground up, ignoring what VGChartz already has in place, how would you do it? What categorical scores would be listed, if any? What scales would be used? Would there even be a score? What should the body of the review contain? This question I charge you with: what should a review be, and how should it be made? |
The review should have the main Categories like most review sites but should be only in the article.
Each category could describe in more legnth how they feel about Story, Music/Sound/, Gameply/Mechanics, Concept, Graphics.
May be more risky though as it is harder to give an overall score for author.
Story
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music/Sound
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gameply/Mechanics
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Concept
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Graphics
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Short Descriptions of Cons and Pros at end pf Article
Story
+ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music/Sound
+ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gameply/Mechanics
+ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Concept
+ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Graphics
+ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score - ?/10 (Based on authors decision)
FootballFan - "GT has never been bigger than Halo. Now do a comparison between the two attach ratios and watch GT get stomped by Halo. Reach will sell 5 million more than GT5. Quote me on it."
