Who else doesn't give a hoot about VG Chartz game ratings?

[scottie]

Khuutra said:

Squilliam said:
I don't have an issue with the reviews, I have an issue with the scores. I find the 3 tier system of value, presentation etc to be unhelpful. So many things get thrown together within these different categories it makes it difficult to seperate the relevant information from the information from the information which is irrelevent to me.

If you were to set down an ideal scoring system, how would you do so? Keep in mind this is hypothetical, so feel free to go nuts.

 

I've already gone on record saying that I really like the VGChartz reviews, but I do agree with Squilliam that perhaps having more than 3 sections would help. If I were organising it, I would have

 

Graphics

Sound

Controls

Value (multiplayer and online would come into it here)

Gameplay

Innovation