VGchartz reviews: way too nice and illogical!!!

[thekitchensink]

DKII said:

Barozi said:

That is true, but then again the average is at 93 for the 360 version, meaning there is quite a big discrepancy.

Even more for GoW:CoO. The score on VGChartz is the 2nd lowest the game has received on Metacrtic. (91 average)

 

Anything above or below 10 points from the average is not accurate IMO (speaking only about high profile games)

What if SMG would have gotten a 8.7 or 8.5 ? Blasphemy ! Not a single reviewer on Metacritic gave it a score below 90.

 

Sure, from now on we'll just copy Metacritic scores instead of thinking for ourselves.

Nah--then we'll get accuses of just going with the hype.