F.E.A.R. 2 or Killzone 2

[Kantor]

vlad321 said:

FSolid_Raiden said:
Oh, and as for the argument that F.E.A.R. 2 will be better because it's from a developer with a stronger track record. Remember Haze. Wasn't Free Radical a developer with a strong track record with such amazing games as Golden Eye and Timesplitters?

 

Free Radical made GoldenEye? EPIC FAIL, this is what Free radical made:

• TimeSplitters (2000) for PlayStation 2
• TimeSplitters 2 (2002) for PlayStation 2, GameCube and Xbox
• Second Sight (2004) for PlayStation 2, GameCube, Xbox and Windows
• TimeSplitters Future Perfect (2005) for PlayStation 2, GameCube and Xbox
• Haze (2008) for PlayStation 3

 

For the record, Rare made GoldenEye.Of the 5 games mentioned above, the only one that could really be classified as truly great is TimeSplitters 2. You can also putFuture Perfect in that category as well. Now let's look at Monolith's great games:

FEAR

Condemned 2

Tron 2.0

NOLF 2

AVP2

NOLF

And that's just off the top of my head. I'd kill for a NOLF 3 or an AVP 3 by them too....

 

So, are Guerilla redeemed, and can we now accept that a developer with a less than stellar track record can make a great game?

Oh, and FEAR (the console version) is hardly something to be bragging about. It's about on par with Killzone 1 in quality.