By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
vlad321 said:
Kantor said:
^Lol, this is going to get 9+ from IGN and GameSpot. If 1UP were under their old management, they would give it a B+, but luckily they're under new management and hopefully don't hate shooters as much.

 

You mean kind of like how they hated the Orange Box (PC) and Half-Life 2?

 

wait a minute....

 

Edit: Just saw the past reviews in OP.... I can't legitametely, with a straight face, say that a review site is good if they have Halo 3 anything above an 85..... This makes their review almost worthless now....damn... just when I was getting excited too.

Okay, I was hoping there was another explanation, but I'll change that.

Luckily they're under new management and hopefully don't hate the PS3 as much.

Before anybody throws the LBP A+ at me, look at the scores for:

-MGS4

-Resistance 2

-Gears 2

-Wii Music

-Soul Calibur IV.

EDIT: Halo 3 wasn't that bad. It wasn't the second coming of Christ that some people hyped it to be, it added...nothing, but it was still an excellent game, deserving of around a 9.

9.8 is just ridiculous. These reviewers appear to be shooter lovers.

On a slightly different topic, KZ2 > Halo 3!



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective