naznatips said:
Nice job reading the thread before posting ck. For the 10th time, I don't have a problem with the score, it's just a very poorly written review, as was 1UP's and to a lesser extent Gamepro's. I don't care about scores. The actual content of the review is what I want to read, and the content of those reviews was complete shit, regardless of the good scores delivered. If you can't even make a single coherent review about a big game then stop reviewing games. Thei reasoning was unbelievably bad, and there were many valid reasons to dislike the review. If you actually read the thread you would know that, but you obviously decided you were above that. |
I see what you are getting at Naznatips. If you read the Gamespot review is full of backhanded compliments. Anything positive in the review is followed up by an immediate negative. Not only that the reviewer contradicts himself several times in the review. I am awaiting the Halo 3 review because based on this reviewers criteria the game pretty much has a ceiling of 8.5.
