Kantor on 18 December 2008
To everybody who says GTA4 is going to win Game of The Year, if that was going to happen, it also would have been PS3 GoTY, right? How can you have MGS4 winning the PS3 award and then giving the overall award to a game that is on PS3 and is arguably superior to the 360 version?
I don't think Gears 2 really stands a chance. GTA4 was MGS4's only real competitor for GoTY this year, and it got defeated. Gears 2 got 9.5, MGS4 got 10, GTA4 got 10. The path is clear.
(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective 
