Sqrl said:
Nah, my decision will be Seriously though..I don't see why not, the staff is split pretty evenly and each with decent reasons so why not leave it to the community? Narrow it down to the 3 major choices for the poll and say that if one option wins by 5% or more it is binding. Otherwise ioi will be given the final say between the top 2. Sounds fair to me =) |
It's absolutely fair, that's why we have this thread and a poll.
I like the non-grades (worth buy/avoid/excellent, etc.) a lot, but I want to have our reviews on the aggregator sites.
For me the letter system is a bit confusing, since Europeans don't use it. For example the C+ for Eternal Sonata looks like it's a no go, while at 7.5 it's a very decent game.
I do understand the flaws of a % grading, but since it's so common I don't think it will give much issues if we have good guidelines. Out of 10 with 0.5 increments is a good system as well.
