Pirate 4 gets everything.
Whatever Pirate 1 says, everyone will throw him overboard because It is 1 less person.
Whatever Pirate 2 says, everyone will throw him overboard because It is 1 less person.
Whatever Pirate 3 says, 4 and 5 will throw him overboard because they will always win.
Pirate 4 suggests that he gets everything. Pirate 5 objects, Pirate 4 votes yes. Pirate 4 gets the tie breaker and gets everything.








