1UP a bit harsh on Disgaea 3?

[Euphoria14]

ZenfoldorVGI said:

Euphoria14 said:
I am also upset with Gamespot.

They said putting this game in your PS3 turns it into a PS2.

Well, I received D3 in the mail today, popped it in, and yet... still is a PS3.

What a bunch of liars.

 

I didn't read the review, but I don't think games should be judged on graphics, when they are an artstyle, and a conscious choice. Particularly Disgaea, which just wouldn't be right without that classic feel.

The Disgaea remake on PSP was scored an 8.0 on Gamespot. Surely if they rated the PS2 version it would have been the same, if not higher.

They rated Disgaea 3 a 7.5. Not a bad score at all but this part causes the score to make no sense to me.

 

• Solid, consistently funny story  
• New gameplay changes make this the best Disgaea yet  
• Even after you've finished the story, there are dozens of hours' worth of things to do  
• Geo blocks add a puzzle element that makes you approach each level differently.

I thought the best of the series nets it a higher score.

*scratches head