1UP a bit harsh on Disgaea 3?

[Euphoria14]

With an average of 82 on Metacritic, none lower than 80 we can assume the score was dropped due to graphics, as expected. 1UP however took this a bit far IMO and gave the game an overall of 67...

Anyone else think a 33 point reduction pretty much based on the graphics alone is quite harsh? They said the game wouldn't have even been impressive in 1998. Wow... talk about rating a game on it's gameplay.

BIG EDIT -

Actually... looking at the site, they gave it a B-... how the hell does Metacritic take that as a 67?????

WTF????

http://www.1up.com/do/reviewPage?cId=3169596&p=37

http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/ps3/disgaea3absenceofjustice?q=disgaea%203

 

Metacritic... my ass.

A+ 1UP editor and user average.

Also, why does 1UP say it released on PS3 and DS today? Morons.