After E3, who has the better game line-up? Sony or Microsoft?

[Goddbless]

Groucho said:

Since I am *really* sick of shooters at this point, and I consider them all a wash (and the market is starting to agree with me, it seems), I would have to boil down your list to:

LBP (1st party excl) + Afrika (1st party excl) + VC (timed excl? not sure)
vs
BK (1st party excl) + Fable2 (2nd party excl -- MS owns Fable name I think) + IU (3rd party timed excl)

I'd say that the PS3 wins by a smidgeon, mostly due to my belief that VC will turn out better than IU, and that LBP is almost guaranteed to be better than BK. I'm really talking LTD attach here, but I believe the quality of the titles goes hand-in-hand.


I actually think there's a lot more to this picture than the 5 games you have listed, and I would definately consider the PS3 on top, all things considered.

 

Microsoft owns Lionhead Studios! Also you put a Sega RPG above a Tri-Ace RPG? I didn't now they still had it in that area.