Yeah, I mean they give everyone a 3 year warranty, then when you need to use it and you call them up, they just say "no", so those people then go out and buy a PS3 instead. I'm sure that happens constantly when you live in a dream world.
The RROD is covered for 3 years. If you haven't tampered with your console and the seal/sticker is intact, they'll fix it for free. Shinsa claims that his friend got a RROD after a year and a bit and the guy called MS to arrange a repair, but they just said "no". On what grounds did they say no?
If the PS3 is that good, people wouldn't need to make up stories and constantly dig up every little bit of dirt on MS in order to try and put people off buying an Xbox 360. The PS3 should sell on its own merits. Despite being quite sad, it's a sign of desperation on the part of the person doing the posting when they do that, a bit like some sleazy election campaign tactic, and I personally find that it puts me off the product rather than having the effect the poster intended.