By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Feminists outrage at walk on/Grid girls, F1 & Darts models ban. Your thoughts?

 

I am...

In support of Grid girls. 72 79.12%
 
I support banning grid gi... 6 6.59%
 
Indifferent or unsure. 12 13.19%
 
Comments... 1 1.10%
 
Total:91
Mummelmann said:
WolfpackN64 said:
I don't know. The ban is a bit harsh, but I've always been sceptical of grid girls. They're just like those models in car shows: they have no good reason for being there.

The same can be said of most instagram celebrities though (I've seen instagram models promote the weirdest shit in bikini pictures). Some modern feminists are actually trying to limit female freedom of choice, by banning things they consider misogynistic, it's kind of a paradox, really.

I don't care for scantily clad girls at car shows or sport events myself, I don't understand the point of cheerleaders either, but removing the possibility altogether seems drastic to me.

Choice is not everything. They're there for all the wrong reasons. I think it's a bit of a stretch to include cheerleaders since they serve an entirely different function altogether.



Around the Network
Otter said:
1. I think people misunderstand the whole notion behind this. Its not about taking away the freedom of the girls, its about encouraging a 2. fairer culture/3. code of conduct/4. representation in the sports. 5. A guy couldn't just decide to performs these roles because there is no openning for them.

Its about the culture you want the sport to represent and encourage that is far bigger and generational then the jobs they loose, but also less a tangible subject.

1. How is the outright banning of actions of women in the Grid/F1 payroll an encouraging endeavor? Taking away choices is not encouragement of due course and these ladies just lost their jobs because 3rd wave feminists care more about a small minority of peoples thought patterns than the reality of the situation that effect these women's paychecks.

2. A more fair culture? These industries are male dominated and these people just fired the ladies......

3. What code of conduct was broken?

4. Again, the representation of women, in this case women who also own businesses, was just quashed.

5. The market will decide whether that's possible or not. Stop telling people what they want. How many men are complaining about not being able to be models at an F1 event? None? Might as well fire the ladies because equal outcome of a ghost variable is just soooo important.

This isn't directed at you Otter, but the actions that led to this video just showcases how a bunch of Flakes can disrupt a perfectly suitable environment completely engrossed in choice. Those choices were just taken away by a group (feminists) who would be dangerous with power.

Edit - Just to clarify, it's not technically feminists hiring and firing, it's the organizations that have control of who they hire and fire. I shouldn't have said "because of feminists" when in fact it is because of the organizations. Recognition of this fact, however, does not deflect the approach of 3rd wave feminists and their train of thought on this matter, or other matters. Lets not pretend like people can't influence the actions of corporations.

Edit 2 - I actually would have taken the same approach as F1 in hiring kids instead of models, it just makes more sense.

Last edited by A_C_E - on 16 February 2018

Yeah, let's put all those girls out a of a job to catter to a minority of angry and ever unsastified people....

Now that those girls can't to this, they'll be able to find another job in a strip club or something.


This is pissing me off, if we start to ban every job that a part of the population find degrading, let's not stop there, let's ban cashiers, fast food workers, the cleaning industry and so on.

And to be frank, I really don't care at all about events having promo girls, but those women are adult, they need those jobs, I know a lot of girls that are dancers and models, and yes they don't like the promo girls work, but they really like the pay. 

We all do jobs we don't like at one point in our lives, and we're happy those jobs are here, I used to flip burgers, I worked as a waiter, i even worked in a ikea warehouse.

Those people need to get off their high horses and stop acting like egotistical maniac, they don't own the world, they don't have the rights to make that kind of decisions for others

Last edited by maxleresistant - on 16 February 2018

"Feminists" ..... again contributing to the loss of jobs for women.

These are not feminists.... these are just hypocritixal "progressists".



Ka-pi96 said:
VGPolyglot said:

Now, own volition is difficult to determine. We have to consider their economic circumstances too, so while they may be passively accepting the job, it may not be what they truly desired to do. Of course, there could be some or most that truly want to do it, but we'd have to ask them to know. Though I guess I am a male so I can't entirely speak for them as I didn't grow up and have to live in the circumstances that they did.

Yeah, that's a terrible argument. One of the "feminists" in the video in the OP made a similar one. It was "no mother wants their daughter to grow up and get a job like this". Well no mother would want their daughter to grow up to work in McDonalds either, and if it wasn't for people's economic circumstances nobody ever would! So let's ban that too! Just because something isn't the job somebody's always dreamed of doesn't mean it's bad, I expect the majority of people aren't doing the job they always wanted and they're mainly doing it because of their economic circumstances, but if it pays the bills and doesn't make them hate their life... what's the problem?

I think you forgot who I am



Around the Network
Aeolus451 said:
Teeqoz said:

You didn't summarize anything. You wrote a strawman.

If feminists have all this power you claim they have, where does that strength originate from? Strength from numbers? Financial strength? Powerful positions in politics?

How could "some sex negative feminist" guilt trip the owners, if the owners don't feel guilty for the practice (which they wouldn't, unless they agree with said "sex negative feminist")? Do you think some small group of feminists would be able to force the owners to against their will do something that would hurt them financially? No. Unless the owners thought that in the long run, this practice would hurt them financially by alienating viewers/sponsors, they wouldn't do it...

Are you serious with this? This is why I didn't take your points seriously. Most female celebs are feminists. Alot of the media are feminists. Most of the left are feminists. Ya got trudeau lecturing a naive kid that we should say peoplekind instead of mankind when she asked a question. He's a male feminist btw. Did ya not see that pussyhat march?

You're just attempting to downplay the influence of feminists so we can't say this shit is their fault.  

You didn't take my points seriously because of how you judge my character? Surely arguments should be judged on their own merit, on not based on your own opinion of the person making them?

Most female celebs may be feminists, but they aren't the fringe feminists that you are constantly outraged about. Same with media and "the left". 

As for the pussyhat march, again, I don't see how that's related to the type of fringe feminism you complain about. Sure, there were definitely fringe feminists supporting it, but you wouldn't judge a large group based on a minority, would you? 

Sure, the wage gap isn't real, and males and females are pretty much equal in terms of rights, but if you can't see how society still pushes boys and girls in different directions (walking into a toy store should be enough to ilustrate this), then this discussion will be fruitless.

I'm trying to get you to explain to me how feminists could force the owners of these tournaments to stop this practice. Could you answer that? How did feminists force them to do this?

And I'd appreciate if you could stop trying to explain to me what I'm trying to do. I'm pretty sure I know more about what I'm trying to do, so you don't have to make up things to tell me.

PS: Check out the underlined part in italics. If you have to choose one thing to reply to, I'd prefer if it was that.



Such a shame those womans jobs are under attack for no reason. Whats the UK coming to? All we do is bow to a loud outspoken monority every time
The poll clearly states 86% of UK public ( or atleast GMTV viewers) disagree with the ban. Absolute joke. I just hope they keep ring girls.



Nogamez said:
Such a shame those womans jobs are under attack for no reason. Whats the UK coming to? All we do is bow to a loud outspoken monority every time
The poll clearly states 86% of UK public ( or atleast GMTV viewers) disagree with the ban. Absolute joke. I just hope they keep ring girls.

What poll are you talking about?



An american company directed by a bunch of republican supporters and a Trump donor bought Formula 1 one year ago, that's what happened.

Last edited by Player2 - on 16 February 2018

VGPolyglot said:
Aura7541 said:

I've hardly seen any feminists admonishing the decision, particularly the sex-negative feminists.

OT: Taking away jobs that some women take (under their own volition) as a stepping stone to professional modeling is obviously a great idea... Whether there is a point or not to having grid girls is your subjective opinion.

Now, own volition is difficult to determine. We have to consider their economic circumstances too, so while they may be passively accepting the job, it may not be what they truly desired to do. Of course, there could be some or most that truly want to do it, but we'd have to ask them to know. Though I guess I am a male so I can't entirely speak for them as I didn't grow up and have to live in the circumstances that they did.

However, it is still their own choice to work as a grid girl. Not to mention, this isn't some measly minimum-wage McDonald's job. It actually pays quite well and it offers upward mobility for those who want to do more professional modeling.