By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - 35th Golden Joystick Awards 2017 - Zelda: BotW receives Ultimate Game of the Year Award

 

Do you agree to the winners of these awards?

Yes 27 58.70%
 
No 6 13.04%
 
I have my own list (but still agree) 12 26.09%
 
I have my own list (and don't agree) 1 2.17%
 
Total:46

Persona 5 didn’t win best aufio?
In the wise words of the wiseman Ryuji “Skull” Sakamoto:
BULLSHIT!!



Around the Network

The winners are fine except for best audio, Zelda doesn't deserve it.



NNID/PSN: Kung_Kjartan

Mario receives that ultimate GOTY 2018.



mZuzek said:
Kjartan said:
The winners are fine except for best audio, Zelda doesn't deserve it.

How exactly is Zelda's audio not good?

He’s not saying it isn’t good.

But better than Persona 5?  Hell no!



Bristow9091 said:
BraLoD said:
Seems decent, though the audio category could have gone other ways.

Not sure I'd give it to Breath of the Wild considering I can't really remember the soundtrack from it whatsoever... maybe it's just me but it seemed rather... quiet.

That was the point.

But yeah, there are other games this year that I would pick for better audio before Zelda.



Around the Network

No problem. In fact I agree with you. 

There are some tunes I remember and they were good.

But with the exception of the main theme and Final Boss theme, it’s not what I’d consider “Beay of the Year” material.

I have played a number of games from this year and there’s no doubt in my mind which one was the best audio: Persona 5! Damn, I love that soundtrack so much!



Cuphead for best visual design. Any other title and I would have been upset.



Audio? Soundtrack? You name it.

I played both games back to back when they came out in  March and April.

Zelda was really good in that department, not saying it wasn’t. 

But Persona just blew it out of the water. And I never played a Persona game before this one, while Zelda is my favorite franchise and was looking forward to Breath of the Wild for years. So, I could have easily been bias and given it to Zelda. But, for me, Persona 5’s sound, audio, soundtrack was that good. 

The entire soundtrack is actually available on iTunes. Some tracks are on YouTube as well, but I always like to support the creators and artists whenever I can. Just how I roll. :)



 

I didn't say it's not good, I don't mind how minimalist it is but I definitely believe more could have been done, it's overall quite lazy. A lot of other games deserve this award.

Edit: Forgot to quote....



NNID/PSN: Kung_Kjartan

Bandorr said:

Is there anywhere that list what the choices were for each field?
Seeing Zelda went "best audio" makes me curious to see what Zelda DIDN'T win.

edit 1: NM found it.

edit 2: Ah Zelda didn't win.  Best Visual Design. Interesting.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/gaming/news/public-voting-2017-golden-joystick-awards-nominees/

Nice find, I'll add this to the OP for those interested to see the nominees.



             

Nintendo Switch FC: SW-6340-7643-4233 aka Renji

Steam: Lee Roid