By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Horizon: Zero Dawn Review Thread - MC: 89 / GR: 88.82%

DAMN, I should have listened to BraLoD, kudos to him for jinxing it XD



Around the Network
pray4mojo said:
Everything he says though doesn't speak about it being innovative and truly fresh. He's basically saying it's another me-too sandbox game, set in a different setting thus... interesting. It's like saying you can't stand horror movies but Freddy Krueger is such an awesome character that you can't stop watching it. In the end, it's STILL another horror movie.

So only games that are "innovative and truly fresh" are worth of praise now? Or that you are interested in?

Can you kindly give me an example of a game that you feel is coming this yearthats innovative and truly fresh? Better yet, an example of such a game released in say the last 5 years. Because from how I see it (unless I am being extremely biased) every game being released over the past 10 years isn't really doing anything innovative, they do however take their own fresh spin on old tropes.

And Horizon has done that, its created a world and a setting that mixes the old with the modern, gave a moment to ment focus on gameplay and exploration that the open world genre has been sorely lacking for a while..... and its taken more fresh spins on a lot of things that already exist in the open world RPG genre and in so doing has carved out its own unique identity.

But if you can show me a game that is truly innovative and fresh then please do.... I have to get that game.



Oh no! An 88/100 rating! Skip for me. But seriously, the game has some solid high scores and then the averages gets killed by some odd really low scores. Either way I'm in.



PC GAMING: BEST GAMES. WORST CONTROLS

A mouse & keyboard are made for sending email and typing internet badassery. Not for playing video games!!!

I guess I aimed a little too high. Though the 3 review that bring down the score are legitimately crap reviews.



Radek said:
MTZehvor said:
So far, an 88. Bit better than I was anticipating, but the 90+ kool aid that a surprising number of people were drinking has spoiled.

90 was well within reach if it wasn't for troll 50/100 review of US Gamer and some odd 2 60-70 reviews.

Ah, yes. The always reliable "I disagree with it so therefore it must be trolling" method of discrediting a review. A tried, tested, and true measure that works just as effectively as it did on Gamespot's Skyward Sword review five years ago.



Around the Network

Well, I didn't participate on the metascore prediction, But I would have given it somewhere around 75-80, so this final score was much better that I had anticipated.

Still can't get myself hyped for any of it, for some reason. xD



HoloDust said:
Not sure why are people so riled up about that 2.5/5 star review - actual review has a lot of valid points, it's just that score is bit too low...though, one must understand that 2.5/5 stars is not as bad as 50/100, star system is a lot more akin to movie ratings.

Personally, I find Destructiod's review quite useful, it's 75/100, but points to some of the bigger issues Horizon has as an open-word action RPG (though calling it RPG is a bit of stretch in the first place).

So you level up, you craft weapons and items, you can take on fully optional side quests that has nothing to do with the story. You can customize you weapons and amor and get different strenght versions of those two respectively...... yet its not an RPG? What exactly is an RPG then?

And I have an issue with destructoids review.... not just that it contradicts with a lot of what other have said (like its talk of the story and the uniteresting side quests and characters is a contradiction to the vast majority of reviewers out there) but also cause of the things its actually complaining about. Looting? and even more looting rare items? Thats the kinda stuff that makes a lot of other games great whgen down right and he says its tedious? Then he complains about the difficulty, then complains about the open world narrowing into some dungeons here or there (so now its a bad thing to have dungeons n an open world game)...... I could go on.

The only thing I would give him credit for is the human AI.... which from previews we have all kinda figured that its not the core focus of the game but thats still a legitimate knock.... everything else though.....

Personally, I hate it when a reviewer says you are doing or seeingnothing new (then goes onto write three paragrapghs of excatly what is new and diferent about the game) cause to me, if that were the case.... then what is new anymore as far as gaming goes?



You wanna know how spoiled we've become as gamers? A game is on the cusp of 9 out of 10 and people are laughing because it's not a 10. And as for the "innovative and fresh" mantra. When did that become a prerequisite to a game being good? Nearly every game draws from another game.



PC GAMING: BEST GAMES. WORST CONTROLS

A mouse & keyboard are made for sending email and typing internet badassery. Not for playing video games!!!

Intrinsic said:
pray4mojo said:
Everything he says though doesn't speak about it being innovative and truly fresh. He's basically saying it's another me-too sandbox game, set in a different setting thus... interesting. It's like saying you can't stand horror movies but Freddy Krueger is such an awesome character that you can't stop watching it. In the end, it's STILL another horror movie.

So only games that are "innovative and truly fresh" are worth of praise now? Or that you are interested in?

Can you kindly give me an example of a game that you feel is coming this yearthats innovative and truly fresh? Better yet, an example of such a game released in say the last 5 years. Because from how I see it (unless I am being extremely biased) every game being released over the past 10 years isn't really doing anything innovative, they do however take their own fresh spin on old tropes.

And Horizon has done that, its created a world and a setting that mixes the old with the modern, gave a moment to ment focus on gameplay and exploration that the open world genre has been sorely lacking for a while..... and its taken more fresh spins on a lot of things that already exist in the open world RPG genre and in so doing has carved out its own unique identity.

But if you can show me a game that is truly innovative and fresh then please do.... I have to get that game.

Agreed, i didnt say more in my reply to him because im busy right now and i only have my phone with me.



88 is a good score. i Predicted 87 so thats nice.