Rise Of The Tomb Raider

*fixed

1- Fallout 4 (Looks good, has big hype, releases in the right time and it is not a plataform exclusive)
2- The witcher 3 (It is very good, managed to meet the hype, it is not a plataform exclusive, but released too early in the year)
3- Halo 5 (Looks good, has big hype, releases in the right time, but it is an exclusive)
4- MGS (Looks good, has some hype, releases in the right time, but people hate Konami at the moment)
5- Bloodborne (It is very good and met the ype, but the exclusivity and the difficulty will push people away)
6- Batman (Haha. Nope, PC version and WB bs burned any chance it had)

7- Splatoon (Would be deserved, but won't happen)

The Witcher or Fallout. I think fallout will take it though.

Bethesda can do no wrong for critics and they're more than willing to look the other way when it comes to bugs, poor story telling, poor characters and poor combat for the sake of a huge detailed open world. The fact that it releases later in the year compared to the Witcher will also help it.

I don't really see anything else coming close to these two in terms of GOTY awards though. Maybe MGS or Tomb Raider could pull off a huge surprise but thats about it.

Fallout 4 or the witcher 3

MgsV, halo5 and bloodborn follow

From the game out right now the only deserves awards is...

Bloodborne

From the games is coming in the future I guess these deserves awards...

MGSV
Fallout 4


All others games needs to prove something else to be in the list.

None of those. Xenoblade Chronicles X.

Batman: Arkham Knight mainly 'cause it's batman and hence everything you say against batman is invalid.

After seeing the E3 Trailer of it, my vote goes to Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain. Runner up could be Fallout 4.

The 5 real contenders for this year will be:

Bloodborne
The Witcher 3 Wild Hunt
Batman Arkham Knight
Metal Gear Solid V
Fallout 4

It'll eventually be between Witcher 3, MGS V or Fallout 4 which will rack up the most.