By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
zorg1000 on 02 January 2015
Zkuq said:
I have no idea what this used to be, but it must have been a pretty controversial topic to have gathered three pages of replies in less than an hour.

The OP asked why would anyone choose an Xbox One over PS4/Wii U. People gave reasons, for some reason the OP didn't like the responses he was getting so asked for the thread to be locked. Seems kinda childish of the OP to me



When the herd loses its way, the shepard must kill the bull that leads them astray.

Around the Network
KingdomHeartsFan on 02 January 2015
Chris Hu said:
KingdomHeartsFan said:
Chris Hu said:
KingdomHeartsFan said:

Dead Rising 3 and Ryse are on PC, Titanfall is on PC and 360 and Horizon 2 is on 360.

Horizon 2 on the 360 is nowhere near as good as the X1 version plus it doesn't get any DLC. 

Why's that?  Besides the obvious like preformance. 

Because the people that ported it wheren't the same people that made the X1 version.  Plus they probably knew it wouldn't sell as much on the 360 so why bother.  I'm not 100% certain but I'm thinking the 360 version of The Crew doesn't get any DLC either.

That doesn't mean anything though.  There was a different team that ported Titanfall to 360, but I heard they did a really good job considering the limitations they had.  I thought you were gonna say something like they took out a bunch of cars from the 360 version.



Chris Hu on 02 January 2015
Aerys said:
They are Halo/Gears fan for most of them, if you are not, i dont see many reasons to buy one ( me, i bought one because i wanted a next gen console but PS4 wasnt available)


I think you are forgetting about Dead Rising and Forza never was into Halo or Gears but I guess there are a fair amount of people that bought it for that reason but probably not as many as you think or the MCC would have sold over 2 million units already.



LordLichtenstein on 02 January 2015
zorg1000 said:
Zkuq said:
I have no idea what this used to be, but it must have been a pretty controversial topic to have gathered three pages of replies in less than an hour.

The OP asked why would anyone choose an Xbox One over PS4/Wii U. People gave reasons, for some reason the OP didn't like the responses he was getting so asked for the thread to be locked. Seems kinda childish of the OP to me


I made this thread because I wanted to know why people would buy an Xbox One Now (as in from release date to now) over PS4 and Wii U. My wording in the OP clearly didn't reflect my question all to well, and people got very upset. 



Aeolus451 on 02 January 2015
Zkuq said:
I have no idea what this used to be, but it must have been a pretty controversial topic to have gathered three pages of replies in less than an hour.


What are your reasons for buying an xbox one over the ps4 or wii u? It was basically that. One person started to throw a fit over it.



Around the Network
Chris Hu on 02 January 2015
KingdomHeartsFan said:
Chris Hu said:
KingdomHeartsFan said:
Chris Hu said:
KingdomHeartsFan said:

Dead Rising 3 and Ryse are on PC, Titanfall is on PC and 360 and Horizon 2 is on 360.

Horizon 2 on the 360 is nowhere near as good as the X1 version plus it doesn't get any DLC. 

Why's that?  Besides the obvious like preformance. 

Because the people that ported it wheren't the same people that made the X1 version.  Plus they probably knew it wouldn't sell as much on the 360 so why bother.  I'm not 100% certain but I'm thinking the 360 version of The Crew doesn't get any DLC either.

That doesn't mean anything though.  There was a different team that ported Titanfall to 360, but I heard they did a really good job considering the limitations they had.  I thought you were gonna say something like they took out a bunch of cars from the 360 version.

There are actually some cars that are only in the X1 version and a few that are only in the 360 version but most of those will make it over to the X1 version as free DLC well six of them sure.



zorg1000 on 02 January 2015
LordLichtenstein said:
zorg1000 said:
Zkuq said:
I have no idea what this used to be, but it must have been a pretty controversial topic to have gathered three pages of replies in less than an hour.

The OP asked why would anyone choose an Xbox One over PS4/Wii U. People gave reasons, for some reason the OP didn't like the responses he was getting so asked for the thread to be locked. Seems kinda childish of the OP to me


I made this thread because I wanted to know why people would buy an Xbox One Now (as in from release date to now) over PS4 and Wii U. My wording in the OP clearly didn't reflect my question all to well, and people got very upset. 

And it should have been perfectly clear without asking, if the games/features found on Xbox One appeal to someone more than the games/features found on PS4/Wii U then they will most likely choose Xbox One. Honestly, and I'm not trying to be mean, but the question was a dumb one to ask because the answer is so blatantly obvious. If u asked why would anybody choose Wii U over PS4/XB1 or PS4 over XB1/Wii U, u would have most likely recieved very similar responses.



When the herd loses its way, the shepard must kill the bull that leads them astray.

LordLichtenstein on 02 January 2015
zorg1000 said:

And it should have been perfectly clear without asking, if the games/features found on Xbox One appeal to someone more than the games/features found on PS4/Wii U then they will most likely choose Xbox One. Honestly, and I'm not trying to be mean, but the question was a dumb one to ask because the answer is so blatantly obvious. If u asked why would anybody choose Wii U over PS4/XB1 or PS4 over XB1/Wii U, u would have most likely recieved very similar responses.

Yeah, maybe it was dumb, but I just thought people would respond like this:

1. Xbox One exclusives
2. Previous Xbox 360 owner
3. Prefer Xbox One controller
4. Friends
5. Achievements
6. Prefer Microsoft


Something like this..



Chris Hu on 02 January 2015
LordLichtenstein said:
zorg1000 said:

And it should have been perfectly clear without asking, if the games/features found on Xbox One appeal to someone more than the games/features found on PS4/Wii U then they will most likely choose Xbox One. Honestly, and I'm not trying to be mean, but the question was a dumb one to ask because the answer is so blatantly obvious. If u asked why would anybody choose Wii U over PS4/XB1 or PS4 over XB1/Wii U, u would have most likely recieved very similar responses.

Yeah, maybe it was dumb, but I just thought people would respond like this:

1. Xbox One exclusives
2. Previous Xbox 360 owner
3. Prefer Xbox One controller
4. Friends
5. Achievements
6. Prefer Microsoft


Something like this..


Well more or less those are the responses you got so this whole thread was pretty pointless.



LordLichtenstein on 02 January 2015
Chris Hu said:
LordLichtenstein said:
zorg1000 said:

And it should have been perfectly clear without asking, if the games/features found on Xbox One appeal to someone more than the games/features found on PS4/Wii U then they will most likely choose Xbox One. Honestly, and I'm not trying to be mean, but the question was a dumb one to ask because the answer is so blatantly obvious. If u asked why would anybody choose Wii U over PS4/XB1 or PS4 over XB1/Wii U, u would have most likely recieved very similar responses.

Yeah, maybe it was dumb, but I just thought people would respond like this:

1. Xbox One exclusives
2. Previous Xbox 360 owner
3. Prefer Xbox One controller
4. Friends
5. Achievements
6. Prefer Microsoft


Something like this..


Well more or less those are the responses you got so this whole thread was pretty pointless.


I knew it would be these answers more or less before I started the thread, but I just wanted to know which one meant the most for Xbox One owners. So as you can tell, I was way off with my OP, so that is why I ask for it to be deleted.