Uncharted 3 is one of the best games ever made and Drake my favorite character so they win this one easily.

MGS3 is one of my favourite games and Big Boss one of my favourite video game characters, so yeah.

MGS3 is the best game, Nathan drake has more personality than Big boss though, masterchief has no personality. (At least not in the games, I haven't read the books)

MGS3 > Uncharted 3 > Halo 3

Character-wise:

Nathan Drake > Master Chief > Big Boss

Reading the many comments you would think that Big Boss was running away with this one, but its quite close.

I'm surprised to see that many of you never played Metal Gear Solid 3. That is truly a classic game.

Pick it up and play if you have the chance.

Yeh, Big Boss is still one of my favorite characters still.

Allot of meromable boss battles in MGS3. True indeed.

I love Uncharted 3 a lot, but it wasn't as good as the second game.

So I'll have to go with MGS3 Snake Eater and Big Boss. He's a true patriot.

The story was amazing, but wasn't a fan of playing through MGS3. Let's wait 10 minutes for this guy to move out of range and then I can run past. Not my type of game. Other games made the stealth mechanic a lot less boring.

I also have to say I like Drake the best, then Big Boss.  It's not just Drake alone that I like, but his interactions with the other characters within the game that makes him likeable.

I vote drake but realistically, he couldn't beat big boss or master chief.