I've never liked that a game with a score
0 = The game won't run/it killed my family
1 = Horrendous quality/nigh unplayable
2 = Terrible quality/broken
3 = Pretty bad quality/buggy
4 = Overall subpar quality, but may have something about it worth playing
5 = Lacking any particularly spectacular or horrendous qualities, or a game where the good and bad even out
6 = Pretty good, but flawed and/or lacking in polish
7 = Good solid and polished game with no egregious flaws, but lacking aspects that elevate it beyond
8 = A great game that is either an excellent example of its genre, or endeavors and succeeds to try something new
9 = A quintessence of its genre or has massive success attempting new styles of gameplay
10 = Perfect and god-tier game with absolutely no flaws, redefines genres, and probably allows players to experience a form of gamer enlightenment or something
Assassin's Creed IV - 6
Bayonetta 2 - 9
Donkey Kong Tropical Freeze - 8
Game and Wario - 5.5
Hyrule Warriors - 6.5
The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker HD - 8
Mario Kart 8 - 7.5
Pikmin 3 - 8
Rayman Legends - 8
Scribblenauts Unlimited - 5.5
Super Mario 3D World - 9
Wonderful 101 - 8.5
ZombiU - 6.5