Sounds like you did not even play the game so you do not know the hypothetical story we are referring to.  The surgeon was part of a militia group and they did not have children with them. They try to kill you for no reason other than you are no longer useful to them.

Yes exactly. They're hell bent on killing both joel and ellie, for the good of mankind. If the approach was different, then maybe the outcome would be different too. Either way, joel's action would most likely be the same, any one who's a threat to ellie will be killed. 

Sarah was shot by a human.

Humanity was dead to me and Joel after that moment. I'd save Ellie without hestitation.

The factors such as: How will the vaccine be distributed, and how there is a chance it could fail and it doesnt really save jack shit when all the vaccine does is make people immune. Those who are already infected are fucked and dead and the rest could very well be ripped to pieces, vaccine or not.

So no, fuck it. Even if it was a time travel machine, I'd save Ellie. I felt such an insane bond at that point, it's so hard to describe. As if I had a daughter of my own sounds about right :') <3

sine the petition ubi soft deals console always bad even though they earn all of its money from console sales its time to teach the lesson and boycott assasin creed unity on console http://www.change.org/p/boycott-ubisoft-games-because-it-always-treat-console-games-so-bad-boycott-ps4-xbox1-assassin-s-creed-unity-this-game-is-900p-30-fps-while-gta-5-runs-1080-60fps-gta-5-open-world-is-definitely-more-taxing-than-ac-open-world-its-time-to-teach-ubi-lesso?utm_campaign=friend_inviter_chat&utm_medium=facebook&utm_source=share_petition&utm_term=permissions_dialog_false&share_id=FNhrsiuUsAsine