Xenoblade chronicles: Great game, great world, great battle system, great story. One of my all time greats.
Dead Space 1: Amazing atmosphere, real fear ( for me ).
Mass effect 1: The citadel. The first hours. The enemy.
And now the crap 3:
Resident evil 5: What a crap fest. What a letdown. No tension, no nothing, only a boring shootfest.
Skyrim: Very overrated. Not really crappy, but for me it was a total underwhelming experience.
Final Fantasy 13: O how i wanted to play this game. O how i want to burn this game! I played it all the way through, but with hate. Weak story, weak characters, weak exploring.