By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - BEST OVERALL EDITION (3D Mario Platformers)

 

Best 3D mario game (no 2d)

Super Mario 64 11 17.74%
 
Super Mario Sunshine 5 8.06%
 
Super Mario Galaxy 18 29.03%
 
Super Mario 3D Land 2 3.23%
 
Super Mario Galaxy 2 25 40.32%
 
Super Mario 64 DS (This Counts) 1 1.61%
 
Total:62
tbone51 said:

IMO SMSunshine is good but should of been a new character (new ip). But at least the game brought two major characters to the franchise
(Petey Pirahna and Bowser Jr.)

Sunshine had its moments for sure; the Petey Piranha parts were cool and the battle with robot Bowser on the rollercoaster was incredible.  But I hated the voices that they gave to Bowser and Bowser Jr and the lines they spoke.  It was just silly and unappealing to me, as was that whole "Mario on trial" bit.  Also, many of the levels were uninteresting and a bit tedious but like someone else said earlier, if you just play the great parts of the game and avoid the rest then it's certainly enjoyable.



Around the Network

archbrix said:



tbone51 said:

IMO SMSunshine is good but should of been a new character (new ip). But at least the game brought two major characters to the franchise
(Petey Pirahna and Bowser Jr.)




Sunshine had its moments for sure; the Petey Piranha parts were cool and the battle with robot Bowser on the rollercoaster was incredible.  But I hated the voices that they gave to Bowser and Bowser Jr and the lines they spoke.  It was just silly and unappealing to me, as was that whole "Mario on trial" bit.  Also, many of the levels were uninteresting and a bit tedious but like someone else said earlier, if you just play the great parts of the game and avoid the rest then it's certainly enjoyable.



↓Tbone↓

Agreed! This game no matter what is by far the hardest! (collect all stars)



Galaxy 2 followed by Galaxy, these are two of the best games ever made overall they're just better then the other 3d Marios.



The galaxy games are the best 3D platformers I have ever played, and also the best games on the Wii. Really they just perfected Mario in my mind. I honestly don't see how Nintendo could top those games.

For Me:
SMG2>SMG>SMS>SM64>SM64DS>>>>>SM3DL

I hated 3D land, it felt like a 3D version of the bland New Super Mario Bros.




Galaxy is still the greatest, the game just had wow moments galore. Sunshine would be my 2nd vote, i must be the only person that thought fludd was an awesome addition to the game. And 3rd place would go to 3D land, the level design at times is second to none, and it is a game on 3DS that actually NEEDS the 3D on to benefit the gameplay.



Around the Network

Galaxy 2 is my favourite, followed by Galaxy 1. Super Mario Land 3D in 3rd.

I can only wish the Zelda series will reach this quality, or exceed it.



I describe myself as a little dose of toxic masculinity.

I think super mario galaxy 3 should be on 3DS [SMG3D] It will make 3DS such a better system IMO. ON Wii U make something unique Nintendo!!