halo Reach gmv ..they lost their way with R2...thankfully they are taking the right approach with R3

Yay, somebody else has joined the club xD.

You should put MGS4 against splinter cell conviction.

dude it was sarcasm calm down man. I am a Halo fan so... and I voted for Reach. I just thought it to be typical for a member to be voting for a Halo game with a Halo avatar.

I chose MGS4 because it had one of the best stories ever.

@OP what are you thinking with these comparisons!? Surely the obvious choices should've been

Halo Reach vs Killzone 3
Gears of War 2 vs Uncharted 2
SC: Conviction vs Metal Gear Solid 4
Forza 3 vs GT5
Alan Wake vs Heavy Rain

^^That's how its done. Your comparisons are a bit...well...l_a_m_e

i voted for gears of war 2, though it was like choosing the lesser of two evils, as I hated both those games, though at least gears of war 2 just had mediocre gameplay, MGS4 has mediocre gameplay,and obnoxiously long cutscenes.

Reach easily. amazing game.

edit: MGS4 easily.

MGS4 is one of the most overrated games ever. Every five minutes I have to deal with a cutscene and there were some really ridiculous gameplay design choices.

I Still play gears 2 on a regular basis.

I didn't finish Gears 2, I got to where you're flying on the Squid things but it was a fun game. I tried several times to get into MGS4 and I just hate the game. It wasn't fun at all for me and every time I barely made it past the point where you meat the arms dealer for the first time.

Gears 2.

Stealth TPS vs. Full on action TPS? How am I supposed to pick from two completely different games? The only comparison I could somewhat make is between Gears 2 and MGS Online.