By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - L. A. Noire might just be the greatest game ever made.

PakChiuCheng on 23 May 2011

I like the game very much and respect your opinion but it's definitely not the greatest game ever made and does not deserve a 9.8/10.

 

It's an 8.5/10 MAX.

 

The game reminds me of Heavy Rain alot and Heavy Rain is the better game.

Greatest Game Ever Made = Uncharted 2 =P



Around the Network
pariz on 23 May 2011

I'm having a great time with it but I gotta say I expected the dialogues to be a bit more complex. The "Truth, Doubt, Lie" logic is too simple for my taste and not that realistic as you might claim...

If the game had a dialogue logic as in Bioware games or at least Heavy Rain, and then, at the end of a more rich and complex conversation you had to decide in terms of Truth, Doubt and Lie, then I might be more passionate about the game.



Play, Create & Share: the Photography Thread!

SnesTea on 23 May 2011
PakChiuCheng said:

I like the game very much and respect your opinion but it's definitely not the greatest game ever made and does not deserve a 9.8/10.

 

It's an 8.5/10 MAX.

 

The game reminds me of Heavy Rain alot and Heavy Rain is the better game.

Greatest Game Ever Made = Uncharted 2 =P

Would you really play through Uncharted 2 a second time?



Saruk on 23 May 2011
Wagram said:

I disagree with your statement but I respect it nontheless ^^






bugrimmar on 23 May 2011

I love how people are "respectfully disagreeing" and not bashing me like I expected. I thought people would come in here and just go "noob, COD is teh leetzors!" :P

I know, a lot of people aren't that happy with the game. I'm just a different kind of gamer with a different kind of belief in what a good game should be.



Around the Network
alfredofroylan on 23 May 2011
bugrimmar said:

I love how people are "respectfully disagreeing" and not bashing me like I expected. I thought people would come in here and just go "noob, COD is teh leetzors!" :P

You should try at Game Faqs if you want that kind of reaction.



alfredofroylan on 23 May 2011


Garnett on 23 May 2011
bugrimmar said:
Garnett said:

One issue my friend had while playing was *SPOILER ALERT kinda*is, the suspects always run, and they always seem like every person is the killer *END SPOILER kinda*

 

I liked the game from what iv seen...



they really do always run. you watch the news? :P i'm sure this was even more common in the 40s because there weren't any high tech ways to catch a criminal yet.

and every person always 'seems' like the killer too, because there can be a lot of motives to a case. the truth can only be found if evidence is examined closely. that's also true in real life. if my rich mother died and all her sons hate her, every single one of us is suspect to the crime.

If the person didnt kill her, why the hell would they just take off like they DID kill her...not only one guy runs, but every suspection takes off like they are the killer...



*Remember when the world was supposed to end on May 21st, 2011? Well click here to see our short parody video of it [not]ending*

Dorbacho on 23 May 2011

wow!



Dorbacho on 23 May 2011

L.A. Noire is awesome so far! I just found a blog that's giving out the DLC for all the extra cases!

 

I just got my Slip Of The Tongue Case DLC, but I don't know if there's anymore DLC codes left. If you want to check it out, here's the site:

 

http://freelanoiredlc.com.nu