By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Will MHP3 HD remake for PS3 outsell MH3 for Wii (in Japan)?

 

Will MHP3 HD remake for PS3 outsell MH3 for Wii (in Japan)?

yes 152 51.70%
 
no 142 48.30%
 
Total:294

I think it's possible.

I wonder if Capcom would also implement move controls on this, it might give some nice boost for the move too in Japan.



Around the Network
Immortal said:
pezus said:

So do you really think MH PS3 will sell less than 23% of the PSP sales? Even 50%, 40%, 30% is "significantly worse" than MH3P on the PSP but it would still mean it got over a million.  Pikachu's Pokepark is not comparable to the main pokémon games lol.


So do you really think MH PS3 will sell more than all PS3 games but one? Home console MH (and in a generation as handheld-oriented as this one) is not comparable to handheld MH at all, in my opinion.

Totally agree.

It's so sony-planet-utopia since Wii is not Nr.1 in yearly sales. I think PS3 is very strong in Japan, but over a million for that kind of port is pure utopia. Even if the price is 10$, it's doubtful.

But if the MHP3 game sells more than 1million in Japan with a price >10$, i will leave VGChartz. Call me on that. 



pezus said:
Immortal said:
pezus said:

So do you really think MH PS3 will sell less than 23% of the PSP sales? Even 50%, 40%, 30% is "significantly worse" than MH3P on the PSP but it would still mean it got over a million.  Pikachu's Pokepark is not comparable to the main pokémon games lol.


So do you really think MH PS3 will sell more than all PS3 games but one? Home console MH (and in a generation as handheld-oriented as this one) is not comparable to handheld MH at all, in my opinion.

Yes. If the Wii could have a MH that sold over a million why can't the PS3?

 

Nah, the game sales really depends on how many PSP owners own a PS3 in Japan.



pezus said:
Immortal said:
pezus said:

So do you really think MH PS3 will sell less than 23% of the PSP sales? Even 50%, 40%, 30% is "significantly worse" than MH3P on the PSP but it would still mean it got over a million.  Pikachu's Pokepark is not comparable to the main pokémon games lol.


So do you really think MH PS3 will sell more than all PS3 games but one? Home console MH (and in a generation as handheld-oriented as this one) is not comparable to handheld MH at all, in my opinion.

Yes. If the Wii could have a MH that sold over a million why can't the PS3?

Because the PS3 fails at selling games that sell a lot. Do you seriously think NSMB would have topped 4m on PS3? Of course not - the PS3 simpply doesn't have the same mass market appeal. While MH obviously isn't as "casual" as NSMB, all big franchises always have a casual following that helps them get to their numbers, which is something the PS3, looking at how stuff has sold on it so far, won't be able to provide MH.

On top of that, you seem to forget, the PS3 is getting a port. Not a proper game.

Of course, again, it could of course blow us all away with 4m in sales, but trends point to it doing well under 1m.



 

“These are my principles; if you don’t like them, I have others.” – Groucho Marx

Carl2291 said:
ElGranCabeza said:

Yes or No, answer the question and stop messing around.

What question? I already accepted your bet...


Original bet or the revised one?



Around the Network
ElGranCabeza said:

Original bet or the revised one?

What revised one? You never gave any details, the only bet I've seen is the 200k and 600k one...



                            

Carl2291 said:
ElGranCabeza said:

Original bet or the revised one?

What revised one? You never gave any details, the only bet I've seen is the 200k and 600k one...


Over/under 500K. People seem to think that's fairer.



ElGranCabeza said:

Over/under 500K. People seem to think that's fairer.

Considering I've never seen these posts from these "people". No. You're okay. I'll let you stick with your 200k prediction for the game.



                            

Carl2291 said:
ElGranCabeza said:

Over/under 500K. People seem to think that's fairer.

Considering I've never seen these posts from these "people". No. You're okay. I'll let you stick with your 200k prediction for the game.


Maybe you should read the thread, you're missing a lot of posts.



ElGranCabeza said:

Maybe you should read the thread, you're missing a lot of posts.

Oh, so you mean other peoples expectations for the game?

No. I want to bet with you on your expectations of the game. You expect it to do no more than 200k.