1- Might & Magic

2 - King's Bounty

3 - Streets of Rage 2

4 - Sonic 2

5 - Zombies Ate My Neighbors

1. Phantasy Star II

2. Phantasy Star IV

3. Shining Force II

4. Landstalker

5. Shining in the Darkness

1. Golden Axe

2. Super Streetfighter 2

3. Sensible World of Soccer

4. Toejam and Earl

5. Streets of Rage 3

1. Sonic 2
2. Sonic the Hedgehog
3. Phantasy Star 4
4. NHL 93/94
5. Ninja Turtles: The Hyperstone Heist

Should change the score scale to something like:

1 = 20 points, 2 = 19 points, etc.... Otherwise a game ranked 5th place over all Genesis games for 4 people is worth less than some guy with limited play on the Megadrive who selects some little known game as #1. Just to make it so 5th place counts for something significant.

1. Sonic 2

2. Ristar

3. Sonic

4. Sonic 3 & Knuckles

5. Kid Chameleon

1. Kid Chameleon

2. Puggsy

3. Toki

4. Toejam & Earl

5. Sonic 2

1: S3&K

2: Sonic 2

3: Sonic

4: Sonic

5: Golden Axe

1. Phantasy Star IV

Do Sega CD games count?

I have a bad memory so my numbers may be off, I'll give it a go though

#1 Streets of Rage

#2 Ren and Stimpy

#3 Alex the Kidd

#4 The Lion King

#5 Shinobi

#1 Maximum carnage

#2Mickey mouse, castle of illusion

#3 Ghouls and ghosts

#4 Kid chameleon

#5 Puggsy