By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Super Mario Galaxy 2 Ign Review

OMG, never expected this from IGN, espcially when they gave a perfect score to GTA IV 2 years ago...

all straight 10's, can't wait to play it!!



Around the Network

Spore Wii really needed that free publicity!



haha :P LoL, sorry for double post

i needed to change my sig anyway.... : P



don't mind my username, that was more than 10 years ago, I'm a different person now, amazing how people change ^_^

haha :P LoL, sorry for double post

i needed to change my sig anyway.... : P

*smth wrong with my browser...



don't mind my username, that was more than 10 years ago, I'm a different person now, amazing how people change ^_^

Lol. XD



Nintendo Network ID: Cheebee   3DS Code: 2320 - 6113 - 9046

 

Around the Network
Mint said:
Oh wow... the comments on the review. XD
Oh man, I haven't laughed this much in weeks.

"I have been gaming for a long time since i was 5 years old and i have never and will never play a nintendo game. their games are so freakin unrealistic. 360 makes real games where if you shoot someone blood comes out just like real life. that's why games that don't have blood suck. nintendo makes me sick"

"A perfect 10!?! Are you kidding me? It's E rated!!! I am a REAL gamer and I KNOW from experience that there are no good E rated games. There isn't even any blood in it! This game SUCKS BALLS!!!"

"OMG, WTF IGN, MOAR THAN RED DEAD REDEMPTION ????? BETTER THAN UNCHARTED 2??????? NO THIS AINT POSSIBLE, IM GOING TO SELL MY WII ANYWAY"

"WOW fan boy much. I mean they barely push any polygon freaking BS I mean some of the asteroids are like less than 30 polygons. I could MAYBE stretch a 8.5 to a 9 but seriously a 10 for the same old graphics. I mean in all seriousness this game could have been done in 1999 right after Half-life 1 using the half-life 1 engine."

"This game looks bad, I also hate the Wii."

"lol I love how this game gets an easier grading curve because it's a Wii game. A 10 huh? How cute. Now have fun at the kid's table."

And thats just the last 5 pages. XD

Wow. The little 12 year olds think they are cool because Mario isn't in a "TeH cool playstation 3 HD GRAPHICKS" console. Seriosuly made me laugh that there are such losers and stupidity on the internet nowadays. What a shame.



3DS Friend Code:   4596-9822-6909

Two of the top three games of all time at Gameranking are of the Super Mario Galaxy series. Pretty surprised how well this one is holding up. Will definetly buy, though I'm playing like six games right now across a number of systems so I can wait a bit.



SMG2 was made by the Gods, it's too good.



MaxwellGT2000 said:
While this was a well written review and I'm pretty excited about the game, I'm certain this is a great game, but I must state how this just kinda proves the point about IGNs reviews.

Craig Harris also reviewed NSMB Wii, low balling the score of a game because it should have had online multiplayer cause "online is standard this day and age", frankly shoehorning in an excuse to rate it lower despite the game that was made was exceptionally solid and he had to put in online multiplayer as a standard to count off.

In turn if that is your standard then by all rights there is no way in hell SMG2 deserves a 10, Craig used to be the entirety of the handheld team, so he knows that SM64 on the DS had multiplayer, pretty fun multiplayer in fact, if you can shoehorn in online multiplayer as a reason to count off on NSMB Wii you should count off on SMG2 cause you can do fun multiplayer in 3D Mario as well.

Sorry for the bit of a rant I went on but the lack of standards is outright awful and a pain to see.

I think he had good basis for it though, NSMBWii was designed so you could have 4 players on the same screen at once, having that feature yet only limiting it to local play is kind of lame because I would have loved to jump online with that game. SMG and 2 were never designed for more than 1 MAIN player at once, so there is noway you can knock off points for it not having online play.



This game is just so freaking high on creativity it is insane.