By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 14 - Game Thread

trangentspree on 27 February 2010
dsister44 said:
trangentspree said:

I'll answer this post first because it's quicker for me to do.

I'm set to 100 posts per page.

This is it on page 7, just a few posts into Day 2.

This is where WoW asks the cop to announce himself (here and here) 'expecting' him to announce his innocence.

This is where Dweti announces he is the cop and says that Scifiboy is innocent.

...

Actually it turns out that the exchange in question between WoW and I doesn't occur until a long time after this on page 9, where you'll find this post somewhere down the middle of the page (this is way, way after WoW has found out she wasn't investigated on the first night).

 

---

That took a lot longer than I thought it would. -_-

I have ten posts per page. So two of those links were more then useless. I see what you mean now, but I still don't see how it makes WoW more or less guilty.

Why would any experienced player want to draw the cop out of hiding for any reason, knowing full well it means everyone knows who the cop is and they only have to find the doctor to completely screw the town over - and the doctor is forced to protect the cop from that point onwards and so is completely unable to protect anyone else in the town? A knock on effect of this is that the cop has to prove he is the cop by announcing someone as guilty/innocent - and with the average townie/mafia ratio there is always a better chance the cop will announce an innocent - and this gives scum a clear target for that night.

 

(Have to leave for an hour - I'll be back!)



Around the Network
dsister44 on 27 February 2010
trangentspree said:

1. I never said that made him seem scummy? I was giving a reason why I wasn't going to trust WoW when he said the doctor probably protected him the first night.

2. This is really annoying. You could just click on my profile and go through my posts that way. I made this post on Day 1, and this on Day 2 saying why I thought they were mafia then. You can read every other post I have made from my profile.

3. Those two things are not mutually exclusive, the Cop could have investigated WoW and held back saying anything until he was in danger. Also, I have been learning as I have been going along this game - I understand things now that I didn't when the game started.

4. Read my posts. For the love of god, read my posts. You're not helping the town at all by making sweeping allegations without actually looking at the evidence first.

2. So why do you think he is mafia? I would like the condensed version. That entire second post was about WoW and Zexen trying to seperate from each other. Which seems like a weird reason to think badly of him since you know Zexen is innocent. And that is what some of the first post is about. >:]

4. And you are right. sorry. I'll do like everyone else is doing...

Unvote: Trangentspree

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

I'm going to vote Trangentspree becuase his avatar is ugly 

vote trangentspree



trangentspree on 27 February 2010
dsister44 said:
trangentspree said:

1. I never said that made him seem scummy? I was giving a reason why I wasn't going to trust WoW when he said the doctor probably protected him the first night.

2. This is really annoying. You could just click on my profile and go through my posts that way. I made this post on Day 1, and this on Day 2 saying why I thought they were mafia then. You can read every other post I have made from my profile.

3. Those two things are not mutually exclusive, the Cop could have investigated WoW and held back saying anything until he was in danger. Also, I have been learning as I have been going along this game - I understand things now that I didn't when the game started.

4. Read my posts. For the love of god, read my posts. You're not helping the town at all by making sweeping allegations without actually looking at the evidence first.

2. So why do you think he is mafia? I would like the condensed version. That entire second post was about WoW and Zexen trying to seperate from each other. Which seems like a weird reason to think badly of him since you know Zexen is innocent. And that is what some of the first post is about. >:]

4. And you are right. sorry. I'll do like everyone else is doing...

Unvote: Trangentspree

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

I'm going to vote Trangentspree becuase his avatar is ugly 

vote trangentspree

Let's start with this

trangentspree said:

Banjo Kazooie died on the N64

Why would any experienced player want to draw the cop out of hiding for any reason, knowing full well it means everyone knows who the cop is and they only have to find the doctor to completely screw the town over - and the doctor is forced to protect the cop from that point onwards and so is completely unable to protect anyone else in the town? A knock on effect of this is that the cop has to prove he is the cop by announcing someone as guilty/innocent - and with the average townie/mafia ratio there is always a better chance the cop will announce an innocent - and this gives scuma clear target for that night.

 

[edit - whoops]


c03n3nj0 on 27 February 2010

Sorry for the absence. For some reason I couldn't log in at all! Couldn't even get it with an alt

*starts reading*



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

c03n3nj0 on 27 February 2010
dsister44 said:
dsister44 said:
Also I want to know everyone's current suspicions. Just in case somehow I manage to survive through the night. Nao

Especially c03n3nj0 and Trangentspree

*sigh* I'm still working on my list, since you had to come and clear KingFate >.>

Anyways, Axumblade increased in suspicion for me, he just went  along the bandwagon for WoW. People like trash and trangentspree I understand more, because they were always opposing for either her or Zex. 

And then I'm a bit on the fence with WoW... She could be evading a night kill 'cause she's mafia, but then that won't stop the other faction from going for the kill. 

We also have to keep in mind someone got protected, there was no extra Mafia kill one of these nights. 



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

Around the Network
theRepublic on 27 February 2010

I hate to be that guy, but Falcon hasn't posted in this thread since 02/11/10 19:17 CST on Day Two of the game. His profile says he was logged in today. Could a modkill be considered?



Switch Code: SW-7377-9189-3397 -- Nintendo Network ID: theRepublic -- Steam ID: theRepublic

Now Playing
Switch - Super Mario Maker 2 (2019)
Switch - The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening (2019)
Switch - Bastion (2011/2018)
3DS - Star Fox 64 3D (2011)
3DS - Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney (Trilogy) (2005/2014)
Wii U - Darksiders: Warmastered Edition (2010/2017)
Mobile - The Simpson's Tapped Out and Yugioh Duel Links
PC - Deep Rock Galactic (2020)

Words Of Wisdom on 27 February 2010
theRepublic said:
I hate to be that guy, but Falcon hasn't posted in this thread since 02/11/10 19:17 CST on Day Two of the game. His profile says he was logged in today. Could a modkill be considered?

Right now I'm considering asking to be modkilled because I'm fairly unhappy with the way this game has turned out.  The problem is that the ratios are likely 6 townies / 1 SK / 4 mafia.  If Falcon095 and I go away (assuming Falcon095 is town) then it's down to 4 townies / 1 SK / 4 mafia.  Assume 1 mislynch and 3 non-mafia T players dead and the game is over as that mafia T family with 3 people is the winner with 3 / 5.  So depending on what happens today, the game could be over tomorrow morning.  Even if only one person is modkilled then it's still a win for the mafia with 3 / 6.

I kind of want to be modkilled, but any more innocent modkilling screws the town.



Words Of Wisdom on 28 February 2010
axumblade said:

I said why I feel she is likely to be scum. WoW is the person I'm more suspicious of at the moment. If she is a Serial Killer, there is a chance that she'd come up as pro-town in the game under investigation. It's also possible she'd be immune to night kills. Do you even read my posts or do you just randomly say I'm suspicious out of nowhere in the game? First you accuse me of lurking, when I wasn't even lurking and I was contributing uite well to the game. Now you're saying I'm suspicious for bandwagoning WoW, despite the fact that I stated why I believe WoW is guilty....I'm sorry but it sounds to me like you're just trying to throw random accusations to make someone else seem suspicious. e.e

I did take up for WoW yesterday by saying I think she was set up, but that doesn't mean that I think WoW is innocent. I just think that he/she could have been set up.

I think Truck should contact Falcon and ask him if he still wants to be in the game...

You're waffling in your arguments and there's a 69% chance that you're scum just by being in that Unknown column.  My guess is that you're one of the four mafia in that column.



dsister44 on 28 February 2010

Right now. I think that WoW is the least suspicious of the whole lot of you. But more then likely it is going to end in a lynch for him. Axum's description basically makes the Serial Killer invincible, and in a game where the mafia is already overpowered enough I just don't see Truck doing it. So I will side with WoW for now, but since his double lynch plan probably isn't going to work then I will have to just vote trashleg

Unvote
Vote: Trashleg

Edit: Oops -.-



c03n3nj0 on 28 February 2010

I said why I feel she is likely to be scum. WoW is the person I'm more suspicious of at the moment. If she is a Serial Killer, there is a chance that she'd come up as pro-town in the game under investigation. It's also possible she'd be immune to night kills. Do you even read my posts or do you just randomly say I'm suspicious out of nowhere in the game? First you accuse me of lurking, when I wasn't even lurking and I was contributing uite well to the game. Now you're saying I'm suspicious for bandwagoning WoW, despite the fact that I stated why I believe WoW is guilty....I'm sorry but it sounds to me like you're just trying to throw random accusations to make someone else seem suspicious. e.e

I did take up for WoW yesterday by saying I think she was set up, but that doesn't mean that I think WoW is innocent. I just think that he/she could have been set up.

I think Truck should contact Falcon and ask him if he still wants to be in the game...

Well fine... but your argument sounds weird >.>

Yes, it is possible that WoW is SK. But how could we possibly know she targeted ArkZero? That's just weird theorizing. The doctor still could've protected someone, you know, even if they died that night. OR, there's really a vigilante who ran outta bullets, since there's lots of mafia in this game Truck could've put in an extra vigilante to make it more even. See? There's a bunch of different things to say that are more likely (to me, at least)

Anyways, I think people are just starting to vote for WoW 'cause of paranoia of her still being alive... 

P.S. I completely forgot why I included you in that the first day. :-/

 

 



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."