i voted for MAG for the LuLz but seriously GOW 3 should be able to win it.

God of war III

its between God of war 3 and last guardian

LOL 1 vote for M.A.G

anyways either God of war 3 or The last guardian....but Sony might announce a hand full of games that we don't know yet comming out at holydays.

I was debating with GoWIII and GT5.

My vote went to GT5.

God I hope it's Last Guardian or something else, not GOW3. I mean, no doubt that God of War games are a ton of fun, but it's just such a one and done experience. A GOTY for me needs to have an epic long playtime, or major replayability, or a super online mode, or something more than a 10-12 hour (albeit great) one time experience.

i want God of War 3 to win, however i find that because it has come out so early in the year it wont win, for this reason i go with GT5

I voted GoW 3, but it all depends on what other Sony games are announced, like inFamous 2 or Starhawk which might take the crown

Well, I disagree. Uncharted 2 is my second favorite online game right now, so it fits my profile pretty well. It also has a lot more collectables and unlockables than the God of War games typically do (3 might be different though, I can't say that I know) which add to replayability. The games that stick with me do so because I have played them so many times I know them by heart and they become a part of my everyday life. I know it sounds weird but by that I mean that I see someone and think, huh she kinda looks like Ashley from Mass Effect or I'll hear some music that reminds me of KoToR and I have to rush and replay the game. God of War, although my favorite beat em up game ever, doesn't do that for me.

GoW3 sadly...