By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft Discussion - Halo: Reach is Titanic of games, says Bungie

theprof00 said:
darthdevidem01 said:
WHAT IS WRONG WITH SOME OF YOU!!

He compared it in a sense of impending tragedy, impending doom that would be there throughout the movie.

What better example of this than Titanic

As a statement it would make headlines & its accurate

some of you people

case in point

its good they are doing that & I applaude them for making this statement

Halo Reach is their labour of love , they should take every step to ensure its a success



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Around the Network
darthdevidem01 said:
theprof00 said:
darthdevidem01 said:
WHAT IS WRONG WITH SOME OF YOU!!

He compared it in a sense of impending tragedy, impending doom that would be there throughout the movie.

What better example of this than Titanic

As a statement it would make headlines & its accurate

some of you people

case in point

its good they are doing that & I applaude them for making this statement

Halo Reach is their labour of love , they should take every step to ensure its a success

agreed. I don't know why everyone is on my ass though. This is still hype through and through.



theprof00 said:
darthdevidem01 said:
theprof00 said:
darthdevidem01 said:
WHAT IS WRONG WITH SOME OF YOU!!

He compared it in a sense of impending tragedy, impending doom that would be there throughout the movie.

What better example of this than Titanic

As a statement it would make headlines & its accurate

some of you people

case in point

its good they are doing that & I applaude them for making this statement

Halo Reach is their labour of love , they should take every step to ensure its a success

agreed. I don't know why everyone is on my ass though. This is still hype through and through.

People probably thought you said "they are just hyping it" in a negative light

I think they ARe hyping it, but the example is relevant too & makes sense



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Good, good. The Reach take over of interwebz forums has begun.



theprof00 said:
Mendicate Bias said:
theprof00 said:
De85 said:
theprof00 said:
the hype train is way outta control. Titanic? Really?

Did you even read the OP?  The excellent post by Reasonable above?  It's a reference to how you already know the way the story will play out, not an expectation for sales success.

Oh I see, that is a perfect metaphor then. It's not like we know any other historical event where we knew what was going to happen and lots of people died................. that also had a record for highest grossing movie of all time.

So you would rather he use some obscure example that potentially many people know nothing about? Halo Reach is like Hotel Rwanda, yea that sounds a lot better  I think this is called reading too much into a comment. He's drawing parallels between the stories, beyond that your just speculating aka pulling shit out of your ass.

Also some people in this thread need serious reading comprehension, although thats nothing new at vgchartz.

how about Hiroshima, or Vietnam. How about these things we've had called "war"? They draw a far closer parallel and are more well known.

When you draw an analogy to something you use the most popular example. If your talking about a movie where robots take over the world you usually reference Terminator, sure there are others but thats the one most people know and understand. Your making a big deal out of nothing. The most famous story/movie where audiences came in knowing how it was going to end is Titanic hence he made the example.

Just to prove my point you said he should have used Midway as an example, I haven't even heard of it. Why go out of your way to make an obscure example when the most common and well known one is sitting in front of you. Again like I said your trying to make connections that just don't exist, he made an analogy using a well known movie end of story, hes not trying to say its going to be the biggest game of all time like you keep trying to suggest. 



                                           

                      The definitive evidence that video games turn people into mass murderers

Around the Network
theprof00 said:
darthdevidem01 said:
theprof00 said:
darthdevidem01 said:
WHAT IS WRONG WITH SOME OF YOU!!

He compared it in a sense of impending tragedy, impending doom that would be there throughout the movie.

What better example of this than Titanic

As a statement it would make headlines & its accurate

some of you people

case in point

its good they are doing that & I applaude them for making this statement

Halo Reach is their labour of love , they should take every step to ensure its a success

agreed. I don't know why everyone is on my ass though. This is still hype through and through.

I do, do you want me to tell you?  It's because your first post in this thread was condescending and snarky, besides the fact that it added nothing to the conversation.  When you were called out on it you went into full damage control mode getting on everybody elses asses. 

Just because it's about Halo does not mean that everything is calculated to blow hype levels to astronomical proportions.  Why is is so hard for you to accept that maybe, just maybe, Bungie only wanted to make a statement about the story?  Don't worry, massive advertising for Reach is coming, you can make all the comments you want about hype then and I won't say a word, just give it a rest for once.



NKAJ said:
wow so basically the halo game is gonna be sunk by a metaphorical iceberg ,in the form of killzone 3,erHUM..no ps3 bias here....

You know damn well that if any Killzone game ever went straight up against a Halo game, KZ would get it's throat sliced and the corpse would get pissed on. Vultures would then peck at it.



About "some people", from most of them I saw jokes, not hate. And Bungie deserved them, it isn't matter of doubting the quality of the game, but even 5 years old are aware of what they're going to face if they compare something to Titanic, both the movie and the ship.



Stwike him, Centuwion. Stwike him vewy wuffly! (Pontius Pilate, "Life of Brian")
A fart without stink is like a sky without stars.
TGS, Third Grade Shooter: brand new genre invented by Kevin Butler exclusively for Natal WiiToo Kinect. PEW! PEW-PEW-PEW! 
 


De85 said:
theprof00 said:

agreed. I don't know why everyone is on my ass though. This is still hype through and through.

I do, do you want me to tell you?  It's because your first post in this thread was condescending and snarky, besides the fact that it added nothing to the conversation.  When you were called out on it you went into full damage control mode getting on everybody elses asses. 

Just because it's about Halo does not mean that everything is calculated to blow hype levels to astronomical proportions.  Why is is so hard for you to accept that maybe, just maybe, Bungie only wanted to make a statement about the story?  Don't worry, massive advertising for Reach is coming, you can make all the comments you want about hype then and I won't say a word, just give it a rest for once.

Asking why people were on my ass was a rhetorical statement. I know full well why people are defending a comparison that is trite, at best.

EDIT: If you feel that I am flaming, you should report me rather than responding to me. I'll point out that I wasn't the one initiating any damage control. I have a strong opinion that this parallel is drawn for many reasons, not just the one you say it is for. Just because it fits one of the many requisites for drawing a parallel doesn't mean they aren't drawing anything more.

For example, one can describe to a child that a grapfruit is just like an orange. You might argue that because they are round, citrus, and similar in color, they are quite similar. However, for the intent of getting a child to eat said grapefruit, if one were to say a grapfruit is like an orange, I would call that "hyping" it as well.

I don't expect you to understand, you think I'm a troll of some kind.



Are they saying teen boys are going to play through the entire game for 1 boob shot?