well i thought mw2 would have dominated halo 3 and be crowned as the best seller for 360, but i looked at mw2 tenth weeks sales 

modern warfares sales started to slowly decrease every week while halo 3 continues to sell 30,000 copies almost every week since launch

Who do you think will be crowned as the 360's best seller not taking in account halo:reach or the next cod game?

MW2 H3 or Reach (yahh)

Those are only Americas numbers. With others, it should easily be over 115,000 for the week.

MW2 (X360) is already near 10 mil, after only 10 weeks. It took Halo 3 damn near 2 years to hit 10 mil.

I'd say MW2

Halo 3 launched when the X360 user base was 11.7m. How can it sell 10 million in ten weeks?! 

MW2 easily, no doubt about that...

When Halo 3 and COD4 launch the userbase was around 12 ish million.

2 years later and after both games selling a ton load, MW2 opens to around 5 mill first week on Xbox alone.

I don't believe userbase growth matters to a game in the long run, take Gears for example, the first one had great legs. The second one was more frontloaded, at the end of the day they'll sell the same.

So Halo Reach will have massive first week sales, due to all the fans it's gathered over the last 2 years. the vast majority that bought Halo 3 first week will buy reach, plus a good chunk of the 7 million that bought it after the first week.

The reason why it will appeal to new comers as well, is because of the massive marketing it's bound to get.

Comparing COD4/MW2 to Halo 3/Halo Reach isn't that crazy is it?

Anyway my main point is Halo Reach is going to top every game on the 360 and will likley end this gen as the most sold X360 game.

Halo 3 will probably be the highest selling 360 game IMHO

actually those were mw2's numbers everywhere they sold nothing in japan or europe according to vgcharts

Reach will be the highest selling 360 game this gen (IMO).

who? me...