I disagree with the order. Mass Effect 2 would have moved up a spot on my list. Still this looks to be a good year for gamers.

not such a great list ... i for once just gona buy 5 of those 25 games... and the order is all screw up too...

No ME2 or Fable 3 on the top 25?!?!?

List fails hard time. Sometimes being predictable is best, at least you will prevent a screw up.

Damn doubles...

A lot of them... are in bad place. But definitely, zelda should have been #1 and GoWIII #2... I don't know what they are thinking.

lol 2 of my top 3 aren't even in there :D

no Fable and no Alan Wake = no competition.

wow I don't accept this list haha. Any one that puts Medal of Honor over Halo Reach has issues haha. Not to mention Arkham Asylum 2 and Mass Effect 2 over Zelda... yea right. I want a refund.

As I went down the list I thought "crap are they not going to put Last Guardian even in the top 25....poor beautiful looking game" and then #1 came up and I was happy. Surprised how high Batman got, but the first truly was a fantastic game so I can see why they'd be looking forward to the second.

@Zucas: Zelda probably would've won it all if it had any kind of media.  A trailer would've helped it beat atleast the two you mentioned, and probably gotten #1.