Depends who bundles the better game with the product. Got to say, sounds like Nintendo might have an advantage there but I wouldn't be surprised if MS bundles a pretty big game with Natal that takes off. Can't talk to much about the Sony motion controller as really they haven't stated much about it or really been hyping it that much. Really starting to doubt if they are going to be able to release this this Spring. But if it doesn't come bundled with a game, and more than likely needs to be a new release, then it won't take off that well.


So right now I'm going to go with the Vitality Sensor and Natal being about dead even and the Sony Motion controller being not as close. But this is a little too early for me to really know. We'll see how all three plan to release each new product and then go from there.

Wii Vitality Sensor by 450 miles, 5 feet, and 2 inches

I'm going with Natal.

I have no clue really :P
I can't really tell if the Wii Vitality Sensor will go the way of Wii Fit or of Wii Music.
I'll give a tentative vote to the Vitality Sensor but if it does go the way of Wii Music then I see Natal selling better.

Motion Plus followed by Balance Board :) Natal may be 3rd.

Wii Vitality Sensor.

It's the future of gaming, not all this Natal and Wand crap.

The Wii Vitality Sensor will sell the most. People have gotten motion controlled gaming on Wii for 3 - 4 years now. What they haven't gotten is something designed to relax you, something dealing with a very common issue in the world: stress.

It's a pretty big opportunity if you think about how many people world wide are stressed. I can see it being as big as Wii Fit if the software and marketing are both solid. I can't say the same for Natal or Gem.

I was going to say that too but the OP did expand upon the question as stated in the pole and asked, "of the devices released in 2010 which....."

i thought playing games with the wii remote was dumb. i was so wrong. i think the vitality sensor is dumb. guess what will happen?

Nintendo has a history of having the most successful peripherals and the most successful games that use them. And people trust them after Wii Sports, Wii Fit, and Wii Sports Resort. Even Mario Kart Wii was super successful, and its peripheral was purely cosmetic.