Not necessarily- the 360 version didn't have 5000 GS, just the regular 1000.

Does GOW collection really have double the XP of other retail games? That would be similar to a game having 2000GS.

I prefer games to have many Bronze/5GS trophies as while Im not an achievement whore there is an appeal to getting that 'ding' on a regular basis.

Excluding DLC, there's a limit to how many trophy points a game can offer.

The more gold and silver, the few overall trophies.

Look at Killzone, tons of Bronze but more than 80+ trophies. [That's with DLC though]

They made it so it's read as two games and gives you different trophy sets. Meaning 2 plats.

As for the orange box, who knows. Perhaps valve was just lazy j/k 

No, they're just FAT.

... Fat is yellow... mmmmmm.

I'm not a huge fan of Sony's trophy system. However, just like XBL gamerscore devs are a-holes sometimes. I find it strange that some achievements/trophys are worth more then ones that are harder to get so same deal.

Developers need to be more creative with trophies/achievements. Some are just dumb while others are fun to try and get.

I think its a fixed upper score limit for the trophies, depending on whether its a full retail, PSN or DLC.

I wouldn't say developers are being stingy, too many games just fling trophies at you for doing absolutely nothing, only trophies I hate are MP trophies in games where the MP is doa, which basically scream boost or forget me.

The Orange Box doesn't have trophies (i have it and i love it ON PS3 SHOCK!!)

but that doesn't make gabe newell any less FAT

I really...REALLY hate it when devs make trophies and achievements overly difficult. Uncharted 1, Uncharted 2, and even Fallout 3 do a wonderful job of dishing trophies out. Games like COD, Killzone 2, Resistance 2, do it all wrong. I do not want to dedicate my life to one game, and nothing pisses me off more than completing a game on normal difficulty and only having 20% of the trophies. That's BS.

Actually, the WORST offender of this is Gears of War 1. That game is such a tight wad piece of crap with achievements. I completed the game and only had 80 achievement points from it. Seriously. I know, I played it on easy, but still, 80 points for beating the game. That's such incredible BS.

^ The Killzone 2 trophies are a joke, bunch of random Bronze trophies that are incredibly easy, but time consuming.