This game suck balls. Period.

FF12 was excellent, voice acting was the best thing aswell as the superb music

my only quam is i gave up before last part, it was the bit where you are in that temple thing and have to stand on them plates to zap somewhere else, i couldnt even do it with a guide but apart from that it was awesome lol

I love it.

My (or second) best FF ever together with FFVI (I guess FFVI is a little better).

The story is bigger and better than any other FF created.

Honestly it was the characters that messed it up for me and the battle system was not all that.

It was an interesting game - there were some very strong moments - however the development of the game was a disaster and the level of gameplay was too inaccessible for the Japanese and western auidence.

however whatever problems FF12 had were nothing compared to the diabolical disaster that was FF13 - which currently stands as the worst metacritic of all mainline FFs. so people can complain about the massive customisation, exploration, deep storyline, realistic dialogue and believable characters - but when it comes down to it these things are far supperior to the problems in FF13.

FF12 was a least a dense RPG experience - FF13 wasnt even designed to be an RPG - in fact the developers admited not knowing what to do with the game. and i think FF13-2's sales will demonstrate exactly what the FF fans thought of FF13.

The part in bold is true. Not because in scale, but in execution.

I just wish the Tactics team finished the story the way it was meant to be done. the potential of the game to discuss the Occuria, the 1000 year war, the Judges, and the relationships between Basch and Gabranth, Balthier and Fran - had so much potential, but were left dissappointing. 

i think the FF12 team are working on FF15, maybe it will have an online element - but i dont think Wada will make it as a MMO, that would be a disaster like FF14 imo. so i think Matsuno, Ito, Minagawa etc, will be back for a second chance with FF15.

we are talking about XII?
XII got more love than XIII did lol
I really liked XII, I just never actually finished it because my roommate beat the entire game in front of me, and I just lost the drive to finish ;P
Although its been a couple years now, I might hop back into it after Persona 4 :)

on a side-note: My Sony rep said, and I can't totally account for his credibility, that Square might be doing a PS3 exclusive XII HD along side X, not sure completely, but it'd be neat

FFXII is a landmark JRPG in terms of gameplay. Several excellent seventh-generation JRPGs owe much to the game's combat system at the least.

Lots of people including me liked FFXII.

by the way your op might  state the title you mean up front to avoid confusion, you dont mention the actual title until after a bit..