I would put Uncharted and NSMBWii higher up and drop MW2 a couple. Take DJ hero out and replace it with Zelda:ST.
Overall, not a great list, but all the top games are represented, so not too bad.

Props for placing an iphone game on that list.. Geo-Defense Swarm is a great game!

I've never even heard of that game before now. lol iphone's not on my radar.

Seems odd that a top 10 list should begin with the best game and end with the least best game. Seems to me this is top 10 but in no particular order.

I know Metacritic is met with disdain by a lot of people here but when Uncharted 2 has a meta of 96 and it's last on a list of games that includes ones with meta scores of 83 and less then there is something pretty out of whack about the list. Hence I must conclude that it isn't a ranking list per se. Though it is hard to figure out what the order could be based on because it isn't alphabetical or release date.

Notice there is one PS3 exclusive, one 360 exclusive, one DS exclusive and one phone exclusive. Poor PSP gets nothing . The rest are all multiplat. Talk about a "politically" neutral list.

MW2/ODST lol
or pfff ...

Dj Hero too ...

No Forza Motorsport 3?

What a coincidence that the first three games are from Activicion...

Personally, I'd reverse that list, then swap batman AA and ass creed.

seriously, that's some oddness right thar

as expected of a non-gaming mag.

Poor list.

Seems desperate to try to remain as non-partisan as possible (e.g. only 1 PS3 exclusive, only 1 360 exclusive, etc) and even then makes some bad choices (DJ Hero should not be in there, let alone at no.3).

Reviews are all generic and brief, so don't even know if the compiler has actually played them all.