Well, Time is in a bad position here. They know nothing about video games and HAD to create a "The Top 10 Everything of 2009." A quick check to the IGN Xbox section offered them what they though was ample amount of information.

My suggestion is to let the ps3 do the lists next time. IT ONLY DOES EVERYTHING!!!

This is a total injustice. Seriously, DJ Hero? Seriously?

It's insulting to Uncharted 2. Though I suspect Time tried to stay platform neutral, I dont think Batman or Borderlands should be that high.

I don't think they're doing them in any particular order, because usually you go from highest number to lowest, so the games get gradually better, but here they go from lowest number to higher.

Also, I see everyone's forgotten about Killzone 2 due to its Feb release. I mean, it was only one of the best received games this gen, surely it deserves a place on this list?

Pretty good list. I like that it has lots of genres.

Uncharted 2 should have been higher but this is your list not mine.

Glad to see you really liked Batman: AA also.

It's Time's list... rofl

No SFIV, RE5 and Demons Soul. MW2 is overrated.

Where THE HELL is Dragon Age Origins?

the list phails!!!!!!!

MW2 being at number one is a joke. It has a place in the top 10, but not there. Scribblenauts shouldn't even be on the list!

And I don't understand how many of you can say DJ Hero should rank below Uncharted 2. I haven't played it, but supposedly it's really fun.

Uncharted 2 should be higher though, and Flower should be on there.

NSMN:wii only 5? The list fails.

Uncharted 2 number 10? DJ Hero, Geo-Defense Swarm, Scribblenauts and Halo: ODST are better?