Absolutely not!
It won't even be the best RPG this gen. Diablo III will be!

i hate when i have to Top things over the others so i wont agree.
if someone asks me which i liked more Uncharted or MGS4 i wont answer. because i don't know.

That's pretty much guaranteed.

Sorry but that title will belong to Final Fantasy Versus XIII with RoF as a close 2nd.

FF XIII should be the best JRPG this gen, even better than Valkyria Chronicles or Demon's Souls.

On the other hand, I think MGS4 will still be the best game this gen (my opinion). But I guess we'll have to wait for reviews.

FF13 isn't going to be as successful as FF7 or FFX. Lots of western gamers are bashing the emo, melodramatic soap opera nature of jrpgs (and by jrpgs they basically mean Square-Enix. lol Not all jrpgs are like that but since Square-Enix games are like that, people ignorantly generalize to all jrpgs) these days. And they are bashing these games for being too linear (I don't think this is necessarily a bad thing but non-linearity makes jrpgs more enjoyable. In the NES Dragon Quests and Final Fantasy, there was a lot more freedom in where you could go). Final Fantasy is directly responsible for the many criticisms that westerners have about jrpgs.

The critics however always buy into the hype so they will give out high scores for FF13 regardless. "Wahh, jrpgs are a relic of the past. They are too linear! They are like bad soap operas!.... oh a new main title Final Fantasy you say? I'll give you 9.5!"

Forza 3 got a 93 metascore so I could see GT5 getting a 95 or 96 easily. But probably not better than Uncharted 2.