Well either I'd have heavy rain myself or be playing Allan wake at a friends on day one

Alan Wake looks more interesting but i dont have X360. I'm not really interested in Heavy Rain (other than fantastic graphic) but i might bought it if turn out to be amazing game.

That

I'm gonna go with heavy rain. While they both look very impressive, i've never been too keen on horror games. (Siren scared the crap out of me :p)

Alan Wake...

Heavy Rain quite honestly has appeared to be boring to me so far. Awesome graphics though...

Heavy Rain...just because its a PlayStation exclusive...

i would buy both if i had a ps3 but i only have a 360 so alan wake for me. heavy rain looking on par.

lol @ GT5 but anyways id go with GT5 cough* heavy rain i mean haha

I wouldn't get either game on launch day... I'm done doing that thanks to Tekken 6 being so much of a let down... I couldn't be any less interested in any game, because I do well at fighting the hype until the last three weeks of the release.... Then, I can't wait for it... But, I would first play Heavy Rain, and play allen wake if one of my friends owned a 360.... and the ones who did either got RRoD, or their 360 stolen, and shifted to PS3... And, I wouldn't even care to rent it. It looks like a nice game, but, looking at the graphics of the game...

I can't help but think it's going to be a really short, and straight forward game... The only thing there is to is the story, and after that, no replay value... That's just what I think though... I don't see how they can throw a good looking game like that, and length into 16GB. I'm thinking it's gong to be one of those "complete in 6 hour" type of games...

And then, heavy rain's graphics aren't really anything to awe at..

well Heavy Rain seems to be getting more of my attention than Alan Wake, I remember watching the E3 demos for both and Heavy Rain made it seems like this game can be a first day buy for me