By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Switzerland bans minarets.

Baroque_Dude said:
rocketpig said:
Baroque_Dude said:

The problem is something that can't be understood as easily as you all may think, just because too many people think that religious freedom = allow EVERYTHING.

Just think of this: why the major problems are related to Islamism? Why does it seem more problematic than other religions?

The truth is that Muslims are difficult people to deal with. I don't pretend to judge every Muslim, but they generally tend to practice (in a more or less aggressive way) their own customs and habits beyond their personal space. They go to live to other countries but they pretend to live the same way they live in their origin country, they don't care if the new country has a different culture or religion.

There are so many examples... Don't you remember what happened in France some years ago when a lot of Muslim youngsters revolted against the police and burnt cars? Even in this case, the criticism towards them wasn't allowed and "it turned out" that they were some kind of heroes revolting against the discrimination towards Islam... ¬_¬

There are more cases in France or in Spain (as far as I know) where Islamics don't respect the rules about noise levels (their early prayers, for instance or... surprise! the use of minarets for their call to prayers) and healthiness at their houses or worship places. But don't worry if you're a Muslim, when the local authorities ask you to accomplish the law that EVERYBODY must obey, you can just throw the "xenophobic card" and go to the media.

I know a case of a Muslim that didn't want to pay his part of neighbourhood expenses because the president of the Community Committee was a woman, at that time. In some other towns, they asked the local authorities to close the swimming pools to the general public, one day a week, for their women to take a bath. Some Muslims openly say that they want to spread the Muslim kingdom "with the wombs" of their women (this happens in Spain, especially, where they had been reigning after an invasion, back in the 8th century).

On the other hand, as a Christian you can't go to a Muslim country and openly profess your faith, in most of the cases.

Some European countries are worried about this issue, but they are not even allowed to show their concern because they would be automatically catalogued as racist and intolerant.

Yes, Muslims MUST have their freedom, but so does the other people.

Obviously common sense has to play a factor here. People shouldn't go out of their way and hamper their own lives for another religion. On the other hand, most of what you described is either anecdotal or fine in my eyes.

Some people that must deal with this issues on a frequent basis don't think that this is "anecdotal or fine", surely.

The French Muslims had a pretty damned good reason to revolt. The unemployment rate and bigotry toward them was stifling the community.

Can you tell me where did this bigotry come from? I can tell you that it is mere racism, sometimes, but NOT ALWAYS. Why does this seem to happen only with Muslims? Don't you think that their peculiar attitude towards the "recipient" country has something to do?

And bringing up what a Christian can do in a Muslim country is a deflection of the argument. The US openly admitted to torture and we were lambasted by the Western world for it and for good reason... many people used the excuse "well, they torture our troops so it's only fair". The point is to rise above intolerance and unethical practices, not to accept them because your enemy (or in this case, a religious state) openly practices it.

People love to point out how screwed up the USA is at times (and it is) but I wouldn't trade our set-in-stone laws regarding speech and religion for anything.

First off, I wasn't talking about the USA and its issues with terrorism and so on.

"Deflection of the argument"... Nope, sir We're talking about how we treat each other and I'm just pointing out that their culture is intolerant enough to demand others what they don't even do in their countries.

 

 

The people you're dealing with LEFT those countries and usually for good reason. They wanted an opportunity at success and fair treatment in most cases and I won't fault them for that.

As for people having to "deal with it all the time", I lived in southern California for over half my life. I'm well versed in how difficult it can be to deal with other cultures and people on a daily basis. Guess what, though? You just grin and bear it. You may not realize it but you're imposing your beliefs on the minority just as much, if not more, than they are on you. It's a two-way street and making a little effort to understand that isn't going to kill you.

Are there people who make outrageous requests that impose on society as a whole? Of course. The trick is to realize that and separate those people from the vast majority who simply want to live their life in peace and be free to practice their religion privately. Don't lump the loudmouths in with the overall minority population.

It's the kind of knee-jerk reactions that lead to the banning of minarets that cause the most trouble, not a vocal minority who play the role of irritant.




Or check out my new webcomic: http://selfcentent.com/

Around the Network
Pyro as Bill said:
Baroque_Dude said:

...... too many people think that religious freedom = allow EVERYTHING. Isn't that the whole point in freedom?

Freedom also consists in the respect for the other's freedom, remember? If you don't respect my freedom, what happens with mine?

.......why the major problems are related to Islamism. Bin Laden bankrupted the banks?

well........... we are talking about religious issues, aren't we? That sentence was pointing to the context.

The truth is that Muslims are difficult people to deal with. .... they generally tend to practice (in a more or less aggressive way). No, they're actually not difficult to deal with. Don't offend Mohammed and they are actually extremely reasonable.

If that's your personal experience, I'm glad of it. It's a shame that this isn't the same in other cases.

.....they don't care if the new country has a different culture or religion. Are they supposed to convert?

Nope, they are just supposed to respect. Isn't it easy? Don't change my words, that's ridiculous.

There are more cases in France or in Spain (as far as I know) where Islamics don't respect the rules about noise levels. I'm woken by church bells every Sunday morning on the hour. I wish them Christians would respect noise levels.

I agree with you, but does this make minarets better?

.......and healthiness at their houses or worship places.  Now that's just rude.

That's not rude! I'm not talking about personal hygiene or something like that, I'm speaking about the fact that sometimes they do sacrifices or cook without having a special permission.

In some other towns, they asked the local authorities to close the swimming pools to the general public, one day a week, for their women to take a bath. Probably because the pool will make extra money. Take a bath? Are you sure they didn't go there to have a swim?

Nah, to take a bath sounds classier.

On the other hand, as a Christian you can't go to a Muslim country and openly profess your faith, in most of the cases. No, that's not true, most majority-muslim countries have a christian population too. Some might not allow churches but I don't see many mosques in the holy see either and their are only FOUR minarets in Switzerland.

I personally know cases of people living their faith in secret.

Yes, Muslims MUST have their freedom, but so does the other people.

 

 



"I think that I don't think."

- Soli Deo Gloria -

The FUTURE is the FUTURE. Now... B_E_L_I_E_V_E!

You don't get a freedom to avoid cultures you don't like. That's just stupid.

Which seems to be your only issue.

The Muslim call to prayer is no different then a number of other things that are well respected... if it bothers you... get better insulation for your house or apartment.

Also... nobody actually uses minarets for that anymore. They've got loudspeakers now. Those will work just as well on the roof then on a little minaret.



rocketpig said:
Baroque_Dude said:
rocketpig said:
Baroque_Dude said:
[...]

Obviously common sense has to play a factor here. People shouldn't go out of their way and hamper their own lives for another religion. On the other hand, most of what you described is either anecdotal or fine in my eyes.

Some people that must deal with this issues on a frequent basis don't think that this is "anecdotal or fine", surely.

The French Muslims had a pretty damned good reason to revolt. The unemployment rate and bigotry toward them was stifling the community.

Can you tell me where did this bigotry come from? I can tell you that it is mere racism, sometimes, but NOT ALWAYS. Why does this seem to happen only with Muslims? Don't you think that their peculiar attitude towards the "recipient" country has something to do?

And bringing up what a Christian can do in a Muslim country is a deflection of the argument. The US openly admitted to torture and we were lambasted by the Western world for it and for good reason... many people used the excuse "well, they torture our troops so it's only fair". The point is to rise above intolerance and unethical practices, not to accept them because your enemy (or in this case, a religious state) openly practices it.

People love to point out how screwed up the USA is at times (and it is) but I wouldn't trade our set-in-stone laws regarding speech and religion for anything.

First off, I wasn't talking about the USA and its issues with terrorism and so on.

"Deflection of the argument"... Nope, sir We're talking about how we treat each other and I'm just pointing out that their culture is intolerant enough to demand others what they don't even do in their countries.

 

 

The people you're dealing with LEFT those countries and usually for good reason. They wanted an opportunity at success and fair treatment in most cases and I won't fault them for that.

Yes, it might be like this, in some cases.

As for people having to "deal with it all the time", I lived in southern California for over half my life. I'm well versed in how difficult it can be to deal with other cultures and people on a daily basis. Guess what, though? You just grin and bear it. You may not realize it but you're imposing your beliefs on the minority just as much, if not more, than they are on you. It's a two-way street and making a little effort to understand that isn't going to kill you.

I understand, but I think that every country has the right to preserve its own identity in its own territory, as you would like to preserve your "rules" in your house, not in your neighbour's house. This has many different approaches, though, so it's not an easy task to balance things all the time. I think that we agree on this.

Are there people who make outrageous requests that impose on society as a whole? Of course. The trick is to realize that and separate those people from the vast majority who simply want to live their life in peace and be free to practice their religion privately. Don't lump the loudmouths in with the overall minority population.

It's the kind of knee-jerk reactions that lead to the banning of minarets that cause the most trouble, not a vocal minority who play the role of irritant.

I don't lump. In my first post I already said that I don't pretend to judge every Muslim, but I speak about GENERAL behaviours that I've observed in my life.

 



"I think that I don't think."

- Soli Deo Gloria -

The FUTURE is the FUTURE. Now... B_E_L_I_E_V_E!

Kasz216 said:

You don't get a freedom to avoid cultures you don't like. That's just stupid.
Which seems to be your only issue.

Did I say that I want to avoid other cultures? That's just stupid.


The Muslim call to prayer is no different then a number of other things that are well respected... if it bothers you... get better insulation for your house or apartment.

Is this your better advice? Aren't we supposed to respect each other?


Also... nobody actually uses minarets for that anymore. They've got loudspeakers now. Those will work just as well on the roof then on a little minaret.

I know. I'm speaking about noise, I don't care the source.

And hey, what's your problem? I'm not attacking anyone, here, but your post is clearly aggressive.

 



"I think that I don't think."

- Soli Deo Gloria -

The FUTURE is the FUTURE. Now... B_E_L_I_E_V_E!

Around the Network

the basic problem is, as I see it, that the actions of a small group are generalized: 9.11 was done by Muslems --> Muslems are bad --> bad attitude towards Muslems --> Muslems think the world is being unfair to them --> more anti-christian Muslems and repeat. I'm not saying all Muslems become Racist, its just harder for them to integrate in our culture.



Romance is like playing Mastermind except the girl never tells you which pegs you got right. - Seanbaby

Baroque_Dude said:

Kasz216 said:

You don't get a freedom to avoid cultures you don't like. That's just stupid.
Which seems to be your only issue.

Did I say that I want to avoid other cultures? That's just stupid.


The Muslim call to prayer is no different then a number of other things that are well respected... if it bothers you... get better insulation for your house or apartment.

Is this your better advice? Aren't we supposed to respect each other?


Also... nobody actually uses minarets for that anymore. They've got loudspeakers now. Those will work just as well on the roof then on a little minaret.

I know. I'm speaking about noise, I don't care the source.

And hey, what's your problem? I'm not attacking anyone, here, but your post is clearly aggressive.

 

Your being incredibly intolerant.  You are attacking a culture for... well stupid reasons.  None of your active rights are being infringed nor is anyone disrespecting you.

Active rights trump Passive wishes.

You don't have a "right" to not have to listen to muslim stuff... period.

 



Kasz216 said:
Baroque_Dude said:

Kasz216 said:

You don't get a freedom to avoid cultures you don't like. That's just stupid.
Which seems to be your only issue.

Did I say that I want to avoid other cultures? That's just stupid.


The Muslim call to prayer is no different then a number of other things that are well respected... if it bothers you... get better insulation for your house or apartment.

Is this your better advice? Aren't we supposed to respect each other?


Also... nobody actually uses minarets for that anymore. They've got loudspeakers now. Those will work just as well on the roof then on a little minaret.

I know. I'm speaking about noise, I don't care the source.

And hey, what's your problem? I'm not attacking anyone, here, but your post is clearly aggressive.

Your being incredibly intolerant.  You are attacking a culture for... well stupid reasons.  None of your active rights are being infringed nor is anyone disrespecting you.

Active rights trump Passive wishes.

You don't have a "right" to not have to listen to muslim stuff... period.

You're not replying what I say, actually. Despite my efforts of being kind, you're just sticking to your rude attitude towards me, while I was civilly discussing here. Nobody else, but you, is talking to me like that.

You call me intolerant but you show no tolerance for me, and that makes you a hypocrite.

Period?



"I think that I don't think."

- Soli Deo Gloria -

The FUTURE is the FUTURE. Now... B_E_L_I_E_V_E!

Baroque_Dude said:
Kasz216 said:
Baroque_Dude said:

Kasz216 said:

You don't get a freedom to avoid cultures you don't like. That's just stupid.
Which seems to be your only issue.

Did I say that I want to avoid other cultures? That's just stupid.


The Muslim call to prayer is no different then a number of other things that are well respected... if it bothers you... get better insulation for your house or apartment.

Is this your better advice? Aren't we supposed to respect each other?


Also... nobody actually uses minarets for that anymore. They've got loudspeakers now. Those will work just as well on the roof then on a little minaret.

I know. I'm speaking about noise, I don't care the source.

And hey, what's your problem? I'm not attacking anyone, here, but your post is clearly aggressive.

Your being incredibly intolerant.  You are attacking a culture for... well stupid reasons.  None of your active rights are being infringed nor is anyone disrespecting you.

Active rights trump Passive wishes.

You don't have a "right" to not have to listen to muslim stuff... period.

You're not replying what I say, actually. Despite my efforts of being kind, you're just sticking to your rude attitude towards me, while I was civilly discussing here. Nobody else, but you, is talking to me like that.

You call me intolerant but you show no tolerance for me, and that makes you a hypocrite.

Period?

Yes, period.

Hearing a muslim prayer every now and again doesn't negativly impact your life.

Nor does hearing a churchbell or anything else like that negaticly impact your life.

Forcing people to not be able to practice their religion does however negativly impact their lives.



Kasz216 said:
Baroque_Dude said:
Kasz216 said:
Baroque_Dude said:

Kasz216 said:

You don't get a freedom to avoid cultures you don't like. That's just stupid.
Which seems to be your only issue.

Did I say that I want to avoid other cultures? That's just stupid.


The Muslim call to prayer is no different then a number of other things that are well respected... if it bothers you... get better insulation for your house or apartment.

Is this your better advice? Aren't we supposed to respect each other?


Also... nobody actually uses minarets for that anymore. They've got loudspeakers now. Those will work just as well on the roof then on a little minaret.

I know. I'm speaking about noise, I don't care the source.

And hey, what's your problem? I'm not attacking anyone, here, but your post is clearly aggressive.

Your being incredibly intolerant.  You are attacking a culture for... well stupid reasons.  None of your active rights are being infringed nor is anyone disrespecting you.

Active rights trump Passive wishes.

You don't have a "right" to not have to listen to muslim stuff... period.

You're not replying what I say, actually. Despite my efforts of being kind, you're just sticking to your rude attitude towards me, while I was civilly discussing here. Nobody else, but you, is talking to me like that.

You call me intolerant but you show no tolerance for me, and that makes you a hypocrite.

Period?

Yes, period.

Hearing a muslim prayer every now and again doesn't negativly impact your life.

Nor does hearing a churchbell or anything else like that negaticly impact your life.

Forcing people to not be able to practice their religion does however negativly impact their lives.

So, you're reducing my whole argumentation into a simlpe complaint because of the Muslim prayers. My post was far more complex, but we agree on "period", so yes, we should better leave it in "period".



"I think that I don't think."

- Soli Deo Gloria -

The FUTURE is the FUTURE. Now... B_E_L_I_E_V_E!