KillZone 2 was SuperHype!!! Killzone 2 most hype 2nd to only Halo 3, but Halo 3 didn't disappoint people as much as KillZone 2. Heck I was on last weekend playing social slayer with my brothers and there was almost a million online playing Halo 3.

Gta iv, Cod 4, Halo 3, Killzone 2. I think resistance 2 was quite good tho, certainly prefer it to halo 3 and killzone 2. Gears 2 was an extremely good game. Also i strongly disagree with the people saying ssbb.

Gta4 nr 1 no contest imo.

 Fable 2

GTA 4 nowhere near a perfect 10 game, a 7 at best!

Resident Evil 5 and Devil May Cry 4, get your act together Capcom your screwing up this generation!! both were okay but Resident Evil 5 was the worst in the series while Devil May Cry 4 was the 2nd worst Devil May Cry game! And finally Super Paper Mario, what the hell was that crap not even close to the quality of past Paper Mario games!!

Tomb Raider Legend came out in 2005, before the Xbox 360 and it got great reviews. I bought it for three different consoles. I loved that game.

to me its GTA.
i did enjoy Halo 3 and Killzone 2 i was actually keeping away from Killzone after i heard its a crap overhyped game
i wasn't hyped for RE5 , FC ,AC. so they didn't let me down.

I also think it's a great game but not as great as I expected.

1. GTA4- never have i ever been so hyped AND disappointed about a game in my life
2. KZ2- loved it at first, but after playing halo 3 at friend's house, i could never go back to it
3. Resistance 2- just really disappointing in general
4. RE5- I like RE4: WE better, 'nuff said
5. LBP- started off really fun then got old so quick, even with all the content

Btw, the leap between 1 and 2 is massive. I hate that GTA4 is the highest reviewed game this gen on meta.

My list is:

1. GTA4
2. Left 4 Dead
3. KZ2

I was really hyped up for these games, but non of them were any good. GTA4 was a drag, L4D was repetetive and not at all what the developers said, and KZ2 story and VA was crap up until the last 2 chapters or so.