By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Will NSMB Wii will be GOTY of 2009? PSSIBLE?

yushire said:
Kantor said:
You're comparing it to Super Mario Galaxy? The same Super Mario Galaxy with a 97 on Metacritic? The same SMG which is the second highest rated game of all time on GameRankings?

I don't think anyone was surprised by that.

As for NSMBWii, highly unlikely. Firstly, it's in 2D and doesn't really reinvent anything, the way SMG did. Secondly, giving GoTY to 2 Mario games in 3 years would be a little off.

 

 

 

uuh... yeah? And I dont think SMG really did invent everything. Its just the same as other 3-d marios out there. But lets wait and see on what the review scores shows up. I know the review scores is different on the review itself. 

Please anyone post back but... has any 3-d platformer uses gravity as in super mario galaxy? if not then I see a huge innovation there for not only mario games but for other platformers...




              

Around the Network

I think it would be pretty hard as Uncharted 2 n MW2 are the favourites to get GOTY.



SuperAdrianK said:
yushire said:
Kantor said:
You're comparing it to Super Mario Galaxy? The same Super Mario Galaxy with a 97 on Metacritic? The same SMG which is the second highest rated game of all time on GameRankings?

I don't think anyone was surprised by that.

As for NSMBWii, highly unlikely. Firstly, it's in 2D and doesn't really reinvent anything, the way SMG did. Secondly, giving GoTY to 2 Mario games in 3 years would be a little off.

 

 

 

uuh... yeah? And I dont think SMG really did invent everything. Its just the same as other 3-d marios out there. But lets wait and see on what the review scores shows up. I know the review scores is different on the review itself. 

Please anyone post back but... has any 3-d platformer uses gravity as in super mario galaxy? if not then I see a huge innovation there for not only mario games but for other platformers...

 

Ratchet and Clank says hi even the interplanetary level design. And I shouyld give props R&C for that... SMG only improves on that



end of core gaming days prediction:

 

E3 2006-The beginning of the end. Wii introduced

 

E3 2008- Armageddon. Wii motion plus introduced. Wii Music. Reggie says Animal crossing was a core game. Massive disappointment. many Wii core gamers selling their Wii.

 

E3 2010- Tape runs out

http://www.fivedoves.com/letters/march2009/ICG_Tape_runs_out.jpg

Ail said:
.
 

EH I was just answering to the guy claiming only 5% of gamers liked pretty graphics.

Based on the HD console adoption, having a console that is able to output stuff like U2 or Gears seems to be important to more than a few percent of the gamers out there.

People need to stop acting like everyone is on a crusade to get the Wii when facts are, this gen, half the gamers haven't gone for the Wii.

And it turns out that those gamers usually are more active in the community and are more involved in votes and stuff for Goty....

 

Just a short answer (i'll try, for once): half of the home consoles gamers haven't gone for the Wii? You're sure?

Maybe some people like you only have one console, PS3 or X360... or like me, only have Wii (and DS)... but when you look at many users here on VGC, you often see Wii as their second or third platform... or the other way around: PS3 or X360 as their second and/or third platform...

Many "hardcore" gamers are more open-minded than you or me, or maybe just have more money to spend on hardware... but anyway, "multiplatform gamers" is a sure thing, and so i can safely say that nealy 2/3 of ALL the home console gamers have gone for Wii, as the different userbases are sometimes mixed...

And my last point: it's a huge Wii userbase, and i still don't understand why a multiplatform owner is "hardcore" when he has PS360, but suddenly becomes "casual" if he owns a Wii as well: if you consider that type of gamers, plus the all the "core" Nintendo gamers, there's really a market and a lot of potential for "hardcore" games on Wii as well... now, if only more good games could be made... but that's another point...



 

"A beautiful drawing in 480i will stay beautiful forever...

and an ugly drawing in 1080p will stay ugly forever..."

yushire said:
SuperAdrianK said:
yushire said:
Kantor said:
You're comparing it to Super Mario Galaxy? The same Super Mario Galaxy with a 97 on Metacritic? The same SMG which is the second highest rated game of all time on GameRankings?

I don't think anyone was surprised by that.

As for NSMBWii, highly unlikely. Firstly, it's in 2D and doesn't really reinvent anything, the way SMG did. Secondly, giving GoTY to 2 Mario games in 3 years would be a little off.

 

 

 

uuh... yeah? And I dont think SMG really did invent everything. Its just the same as other 3-d marios out there. But lets wait and see on what the review scores shows up. I know the review scores is different on the review itself. 

Please anyone post back but... has any 3-d platformer uses gravity as in super mario galaxy? if not then I see a huge innovation there for not only mario games but for other platformers...

 

Ratchet and Clank says hi even the interplanetary level design. And I shouyld give props R&C for that... SMG only improves on that

Did Ratchet and Clank have you running around sideways and upsidown, dodging enemies and projectiles on a spherical grid?  The real innovation of Mario Galaxy is not simply 'interplanety level design', its the fact that they took the traditionally flat Platformer genre and made it truly 3D, putting you in worlds that were spherical and fully interactive on a new level beyond just running on a flat plane.  In other words, its the next step beyond Mario 64.

'Interplanetry Level Design' could be traced back to Kirby or even earlier if you wanted to make that weak argument.



Six upcoming games you should look into:

 

  

Around the Network

Wowzers, people, quiet down a little bit... :s This thread is derailing fast.

Fact is NSMBW and SMG are two entirely different games, and just because SMG won several GOTY awards doesn't mean NSMBW can or can't. Looks unlikely, but right now, no-one knows, we'll just have to wait and see.



Nintendo Network ID: Cheebee   3DS Code: 2320 - 6113 - 9046

 

It won't, and that's all for me. I hope it gets critical acclaim though =/



 

 

 

 

 

GOTY? better than Uncharted 2?



I regret making this my username, I made this name when I was 13 years old

Life could always get worse, you could be a mod for Neogaf

Has anyone mentioned Arkham Asylum yet? It won't win, but has a good chance of being nominated. As for NSMBWii, I think the competition will be too stiff...



Wii code: 1534 8127 5081 0969

Brawl code: 1762-4131-9390

Member of the Pikmin Fan Club

yushire said:

Yeah, its far fetched but everyone here shocked too when multiple sites sys SMG was GOTY. Including GT and IGN. And it released in november too 2 months before the year ends. So I wonder would it be possible?

so people were shocked that SMG was GOTY? lol i am shocked that people got shocked about it!!



    R.I.P Mr Iwata :'(