Hm, Chip N Dale should be there, Gun smoke and Guerilla war also. Metroid should be higher goddammit.

Also, Miracle Piano (#76) shouldnt be on the list. This is more a software than a game imo.

How do you intend to control this thread?? It can get out of hand by everyone expressing their opinions. Some sorta point system would have helped

@blunty51

I agree that a certain methodology must be applied to this thread. Please don't forget to give us your thought on the list. More opinions = better list.

^^ Indeed I'll get to it...just a bit to swallow at the moment

Everything is discussion based, I personally believe the community at vgchartz is significantly more reasonable than most video game message boards, point is too easy to over look something allows spammers and is purely quanititative, discussion is better as it is qualitative and most people are being reasonable here so I think it will work

Even though my list has all 6 megaman games and so forth I'm thinking we should try to reduce the number of irriteration in a series 1/20 of the list being megaman games seems like it will leave out some really deserving games

anyway some opinions we need

Which is better dragon warrior 3 or 4, I think both will probably be on the top 100, which is better?

games with 2 releases on the console (r.c pro am, duck tales, chip & dale rescue rangers, 1942(3)) which is better the first or the second? or are both worthy of appearing

also atma, your right about miracle piano, I'll drop it even though it is a great product, it isn't a game

also rescue the embassy mission, and dk jr math will be dropped from the list

I'll tenatively place dragon warrior 3 and 4 on the list at 30 and 49 respectively untill we can determine where they really belong

I'll put geurilla warfare at 59 (I heart co-op) and gunsmoke at 76 at untill we can settle on where they belong, or if they need to be removed

the next post will be for the list that I will update, it will be the "official" list,

one more thing, any game on the list you've never played give it a chance you may well like it

This is the original list, I'm keeping it here
Alright here's the starting point, now lets rip it apart and make a better one
1. Punch OuT!!!!
2. Megaman 2
3. Super Mario Brothers
4. Contra
5. Kibry’s Adventure
6. Super Mario Brothers 3
7. Legend of Zelda
8. Jackal
9. International Track & field
10. Zelda 2
11. Ninja Gaiden 2
12. Castlevania
13. Life Force
14. Bionic Commando
15. Tetris
16. G.I. Joe
17. Balloon Fight
18. Megaman
19. Darkwing Duck
20. Galaga
21. Gun nac
22. Crystalis
23. Super C
24. King’s Quest
25. 8 eyes
26. Megaman 3
27. Ninja Gaiden 3
28. Millipede
29. Wizards & Warriors
30. Rescue the embassy mission
31. Cowboy Kid
32. Bomberman 2
33. Ninja Gaiden
34. Megaman 6
35. Mach Rider
36. Mighty Final Fight
37. Strider
38. 1943
39. Adventure island 3
40. Off Road
41. Double Dragon
42. TMNT 2
43. Duck Tales 2
44. Rush’n Attack
45. Castlevania 3
46. Metroid
47. Super Mario Bros 2
48. Mario Bros
49. Donkey Kong Junior Math
50. Batman
51. Blaster Master
52. Bubble Bobble
53. Bonk’s Adventure
54. Rygar
55. Castlevania 2
56. Rescue the embassy mission
57. Battle of Olympus
58. Trojan
59. NEs World Cup Soccer
60. Pinbot
61. Arkanoid
62. Megaman 5
63. Chip N’ Dale 2
64. Donkey Kong Classics
65. Dick Tracey
66. Final Fantasy
67. Duck Hunt
68. Fire n’ Ice
69. Kid Icarus
70. Ultima Warriors of Destiny
71. Lemmings
72. The Last Ninja
73. Marble Madness
74. Snake Rattle n’ Roll
75. Mighty Bomb Jack
76. Miracle Piano
77. World Class Track meet
78. Hogan’s Alley
79. Wild Gunman
80. Ice Climber
81. Popeye
82. Q Bert
83. Megaman 4
84. Qix
85. R.C. Pro Am 2
86. Super Sprint
87. Ms. Pacman
88. Road Blasters
89. Shadow of the Ninja
90. Ninja Crusaders
91. Snow Bros
92. Solar Jetman
93. Sword Master
94. T&C surf Design
95. Tiny Toon Adventures
96. Totally Rad
97. Little Nemo
98. Wrecking Crew
99. Xexyz
100. Indiana Jones and the last crusade, the good one
remember this is a starting point, your opinion is just as valid and mine

I think you should sent invitations to some of the great NES owners of this site : elprincipe, The Ghost of RubangB, joey123, commando, Tecmo, vidiotsavant, rodarkone, kc713, Simon Belmont, etc. so we can have more people.

I will also send a link from my elimination game thread and incite people to participate in your thread.

where is battle city, that game was great. Also, no TMNT 3?? And Mario Bros 1 & 3 should be in top 2, not sure which one should go 1st though.

I'm not going to go into the list like you wanted us to before, but I just think you should go back and play all those games, then make a 'list'.  I usually don't say this, but I don't see how you could make half those choices after playing the games.

Which I have played more than 3/4 that list and own half those games.