I personally haven't played either so I'm obviously in the wrong thread.

But I stand my previous advice to own both if possible.

just go trade it in, obviously you want to other wise you would not be asking.

What everyone else has said.

Even though i dont like Gears 2 myself. I played number1 and assumed i would hate 2. I enjoyed Uncharted 1 lots and i assume that i will like number 2 when i pick up my copy on friday.

But that is my personal opinion.

Hey is the really a big difference between a 94 and a 97. I mean really they are like the same quality. Just play gears 2 if you like it then truade it in for Uncharted 2 when your done

Keep Gears of War 2, and get Uncharted 2 instead of MW2. That way you will have 2 of the greatest games this gen.

@ the bolded...Gears 2 is not one of the greatest game this gen.

It not????   Why is that?

Keep it. Buy Uncharted 2 and MW2 also.

I don't know.  Gears 1 was AWESOME but I feel really underwhelm with Gears 2.  If you look at both Gears 1 and 2 there was a little improvement in visuals but not by much.  Multiplayer in Gears 2 still doesn't feel right.

I prefer Uncharted 2 over Gears 2 because of the story and the platforming. Plus, the online for Uncharted 2 IMHO is funner than Gears 2.

But seriously, dude, it's you who should decide. If you can get both, waste no time. Otherwise, it's entirely your call.

Get Gears 2 and Uncharted 2. Screw MW2. but If you had to get MW2 i would definatly say get Uncharted 2. Even as an xbox fan i hated Gears 2 and i think uncharted 2 will be amazing